AEC-VIKOR-Coordination 对抗择优抽取的具体运用


论文写作或者计算需要帮助可发邮件到 hwstu # sohu.com 把 #替换成@,请说清来意,不必拐弯抹角,浪费相互之间的时间。(收费项目)

流程图


原始系统如下:


$$ \begin{array}{c|c|c|c|c|c|c}{M_{42 \times19}} & -A1 & +A2 & +A3 & -A4 & +B1 & -B2 & -B3 & -B4 & -B5 & -B6 & -C1 & -C2 & -C3 & +C4 & +C5 & +C6 & +C7 & +C8 & -C9\\ \hline 2020-兰州 &163.54 &3189 &21.95 &96.92 &9744 &1112.7 &5977.36 &14861.55 &36.61 &226.19 &47 &76 &68.8 &13.19 &33.14 &85.2 &96.38 &99.9 &6732\\ \hline 2019-兰州 &214.61 &3109 &21.54 &92.49 &8357.78 &1530 &7980.41 &14121.83 &42.92 &218.224 &50 &79 &69 &13.45 &38.55 &81.1 &97.7 &99.5 &24879\\ \hline 2018-兰州 &218.44 &3319 &21.51 &88.14 &8146.03 &1386 &8328.64 &13518.82 &70.44 &201.89 &55 &103 &68 &13.89 &32.03 &58.4 &96 &99.39 &19986\\ \hline 2017-兰州 &223.98 &2801 &17.56 &83.16 &7847.49 &1291.64 &7684.69 &12882.39 &69.94 &173.98 &57 &111 &68.1 &12.76 &30.93 &63.6 &95.49 &100 &15786\\ \hline 2016-兰州 &219.68 &2800 &17.02 &73.14 &7993.44 &1089 &6950.64 &12208.84 &66.04 &148.45 &57 &115 &68.2 &12.71 &27.4 &89.6 &95.72 &40.4 &15892\\ \hline 2015-兰州 &205.49 &2739 &16.11 &62.51 &7750.79 &809 &6153.3 &11801.02 &62.61 &127.11 &53 &120 &68.8 &9.17 &25.8 &88.3 &88.96 &19.65 &45209\\ \hline 2014-兰州 &212.81 &2769 &16.56 &52.42 &7729.49 &700 &7600 &20100 &59.29 &103.36 &48 &126 &67 &11.49 &28 &85.3 &83.51 &19.15 &63801\\ \hline 2020-白银 &14.54 &317 &21.47 &40.2 &12172.25 &0 &1134 &10144 &7.86 &150 &25 &64 &65.5 &11.56 &36.34 &94 &94.35 &100 &4959\\ \hline 2019-白银 &14.78 &226 &21.3 &24.79 &12117.65 &0 &1864.83 &9312.1 &12.73 &164.44 &27 &62 &65 &11.54 &36.48 &93.1 &93.1 &100 &10961\\ \hline 2018-白银 &15.01 &306 &15.55 &22.98 &12579.26 &0 &1924 &8743.72 &12.73 &153.97 &26 &82 &65 &9.49 &36.39 &90.9 &92.9 &100 &10511\\ \hline 2017-白银 &19.7 &490 &14.3 &24.33 &12453.48 &0 &1824.54 &8343.25 &12.4 &146.64 &28 &85 &66 &9.51 &32.51 &83.2 &94.69 &100 &5264\\ \hline 2016-白银 &15.19 &310 &14.31 &22.46 &12502.5 &0 &1817.63 &7583.39 &12.15 &132.43 &27 &88 &63 &9.54 &34.7 &81.2 &78.48 &97.96 &5823\\ \hline 2015-白银 &15.17 &303 &14.9 &21.55 &12190.84 &0 &2071 &8689 &13.1 &156.67 &26 &108 &68 &9.71 &35.1 &81.6 &72.98 &96.95 &9594\\ \hline 2014-白银 &14.89 &303 &15 &16.29 &11714.9 &0 &4941 &11235 &21.42 &227.47 &22 &122 &69 &9.55 &34.8 &84.4 &72.74 &89.88 &10486\\ \hline 2020-定西 &4.69 &532 &14.17 &53.1 &12808 &0 &2152 &4874 &11.3017 &96.0875 &24 &53 &67.2 &17.69 &30.1 &98.1 &95.34 &100 &2248\\ \hline 2019-定西 &4.23 &532 &13.98 &30.58 &12626.64 &0 &2147.44 &4684.77 &11.27 &92.19 &25 &57 &65.7 &16.85 &26.97 &97 &92.8 &98.9 &2618\\ \hline 2018-定西 &2.78 &500 &13.63 &33.43 &10904.5 &0 &2568.42 &4430.35 &11.02 &85.48 &17 &81 &65.4 &16.85 &26.4 &92 &94.34 &98.87 &2468\\ \hline 2017-定西 &2.86 &403 &13.52 &31.99 &10862.83 &0 &2233.75 &4433.87 &12.23 &143.25 &30 &69 &66.6 &16.56 &25.66 &89.6 &92.22 &100 &3141\\ \hline 2016-定西 &6.4 &260 &13.47 &30.48 &10922.02 &0 &2059.84 &5055.9 &11.84 &86.64 &31 &73 &64.6 &16.56 &25.2 &89.3 &88.69 &100 &3374\\ \hline 2015-定西 &5.7 &198 &13.35 &28.09 &10670.23 &0 &2118.56 &3690.33 &11.6 &92 &24 &85 &67.1 &16.39 &25.2 &86.4 &87.5 &68.39 &4612\\ \hline 2014-定西 &2.39 &108 &13.03 &16.62 &10514.99 &0 &5306 &4830 &11.99 &92.1 &31 &91 &67.2 &10.56 &18.1 &85.6 &75.51 &63.27 &4231\\ \hline 2020-临夏 &11.2 &261 &16.07 &49.4 &7859.24 &0 &1687 &7305 &9.28 &120.53 &24 &55 &66.8 &16.51 &33 &88.8 &95.1 &100 &2263\\ \hline 2019-临夏 &10.6 &242 &11.89 &24.69 &7720.74 &0 &3938 &2106 &28 &32.64 &21 &59 &69 &5.33 &31.66 &87.1 &92.6 &97.3 &2732\\ \hline 2018-临夏 &9.9 &214 &10.71 &23.84 &6790.23 &0 &3750 &1949.6 &25.46 &29.68 &23 &81 &70 &5.16 &11.98 &86.3 &94.2 &98.65 &2923\\ \hline 2017-临夏 &9.1 &216 &10.77 &21.69 &6817.37 &0 &3641 &1856.8 &23.79 &27.48 &28 &79 &68.1 &5.26 &11.98 &81.3 &91.36 &100 &3158\\ \hline 2016-临夏 &8.3 &197 &10.04 &20.71 &6781.12 &0 &3371 &1688 &19.82 &22.9 &38 &81 &68.3 &5 &14.5 &85.2 &85.63 &69.16 &3485\\ \hline 2015-临夏 &7.1 &180 &10.77 &19.43 &6749.12 &0 &3122 &1532 &17.21 &18.15 &53 &95 &69 &5.1 &14.4 &74.9 &70.2 &90.6 &36851\\ \hline 2014-临夏 &6.9 &173 &9.42 &14.15 &6681.08 &0 &2865 &1276.7 &14.34 &15.13 &29 &94 &67.8 &3.61 &14.9 &70.4 &71.5 &84.3 &37026\\ \hline 2020-西宁 &74.6 &1920 &12.5 &73.03 &5715 &586.2 &2680.8 &5998.5 &21.15 &62.46 &48 &70 &68.3 &12.82 &40.02 &92.1 &94.87 &98.73 &7008\\ \hline 2019-西宁 &93.28 &1940 &12.5 &67.4 &5532 &812.6 &3823.7 &6861.2 &29.84 &66.57 &37 &59 &69.9 &12.42 &40.58 &96.8 &94.91 &96.19 &24338\\ \hline 2018-西宁 &94.52 &1767 &12.3 &61.51 &5317 &715 &3793.8 &7548.6 &29.71 &127.53 &39 &89 &65.8 &12.5 &40.5 &77.2 &87.7 &95.1 &28456\\ \hline 2017-西宁 &94.35 &1703 &9.75 &55.81 &4903 &625.5 &3564 &7268 &28.83 &122.61 &40 &99 &69.4 &12.47 &40.5 &81.1 &76.7 &94.91 &30254\\ \hline 2016-西宁 &22.13 &1648 &7.89 &49.11 &4622 &510.7 &3165.7 &6952.6 &27.05 &116.77 &42 &113 &69.7 &12 &40.5 &75.4 &70.36 &93.51 &34251\\ \hline 2015-西宁 &22.01 &1918 &7.46 &42.8 &4585 &212 &2592 &6923 &22.84 &124.53 &38 &106 &69.3 &12 &40.5 &77.6 &74.44 &95.27 &61783\\ \hline 2014-西宁 &21.49 &1915 &7.23 &39.12 &4341 &201 &2232 &6221 &22.08 &108.22 &41 &120 &69.8 &12 &40 &73.1 &73.12 &94.16 &71622\\ \hline 2020-海东 &0.98 &170 &8.1 &23.69 &12024 &0 &1013 &3520 &4.23 &48.13 &36 &62 &68.7 &5.75 &35.86 &95 &95.81 &96.2 &18581\\ \hline 2019-海东 &4.29 &227 &10.95 &21.96 &12000.07 &0 &1932 &4538 &6.58 &53.21 &40 &60 &65.8 &5.6 &35.2 &97 &94.3 &96.31 &24365\\ \hline 2018-海东 &9.71 &259 &7.65 &20.87 &11946.1 &0 &1938 &3883.52 &6.37 &49.04 &39 &85 &61.5 &5.5 &33.9 &83.4 &86.8 &95.24 &32314\\ \hline 2017-海东 &3.97 &236 &6.91 &18.79 &9229.4 &0 &1854.63 &3600.65 &6.11 &45.47 &36 &104 &66 &5.5 &32.4 &79.8 &84.3 &92.5 &33912\\ \hline 2016-海东 &3.97 &236 &6.52 &16.25 &9229.4 &0 &1789.26 &3414.15 &5.73 &42.46 &41 &114 &66.2 &4.9 &31.12 &76.6 &82.6 &93.6 &35127\\ \hline 2015-海东 &2.98 &100 &4.6 &16.49 &8887.86 &0 &1825.53 &2748.52 &12.48 &50.12 &39 &104 &67.5 &4.8 &29.79 &73.3 &100 &92.1 &64696\\ \hline 2014-海东 &2.01 &58 &2.62 &13.86 &8599 &0 &1682.82 &2494.03 &11.25 &44.95 &42 &113 &69.5 &4.5 &31.56 &72.6 &100 &70.6 &59817\\ \hline \end{array} $$

采用的归一方法如下


极差法

正向指标公式:$$ n_{ij} = \frac{{o_{ij}-min(o_{j})}}{{max(o_{j})-min(o_{j})}} $$

负向指标公式:$$ n_{ij} = \frac{max(o_{j})-{o_{ij}}}{{max(o_{j})-min(o_{j})}} $$


归一化矩阵如下


$$ \begin{array}{c|c|c|c|c|c|c}{M_{42 \times19}} & -A1 & +A2 & +A3 & -A4 & +B1 & -B2 & -B3 & -B4 & -B5 & -B6 & -C1 & -C2 & -C3 & +C4 & +C5 & +C6 & +C7 & +C8 & -C9\\ \hline 2020-兰州 &0.271 &0.96 &1 &0 &0.638 &0.273 &0.321 &0.278 &0.511 &0.006 &0.25 &0.685 &0.141 &0.68 &0.74 &0.675 &0.879 &0.999 &0.935\\ \hline 2019-兰州 &0.042 &0.936 &0.979 &0.053 &0.474 &0 &0.048 &0.318 &0.416 &0.044 &0.175 &0.644 &0.118 &0.699 &0.929 &0.572 &0.923 &0.994 &0.674\\ \hline 2018-兰州 &0.025 &1 &0.977 &0.106 &0.449 &0.094 &0 &0.35 &0 &0.12 &0.05 &0.315 &0.235 &0.73 &0.701 &0 &0.866 &0.992 &0.744\\ \hline 2017-兰州 &0 &0.841 &0.773 &0.166 &0.414 &0.156 &0.088 &0.383 &0.008 &0.252 &0 &0.205 &0.224 &0.65 &0.663 &0.131 &0.849 &1 &0.805\\ \hline 2016-兰州 &0.019 &0.841 &0.745 &0.286 &0.431 &0.288 &0.188 &0.419 &0.066 &0.372 &0 &0.151 &0.212 &0.646 &0.539 &0.786 &0.856 &0.263 &0.803\\ \hline 2015-兰州 &0.083 &0.822 &0.698 &0.414 &0.403 &0.471 &0.297 &0.441 &0.118 &0.473 &0.1 &0.082 &0.141 &0.395 &0.483 &0.753 &0.63 &0.006 &0.381\\ \hline 2014-兰州 &0.05 &0.831 &0.721 &0.536 &0.4 &0.542 &0.1 &0 &0.168 &0.584 &0.225 &0 &0.353 &0.56 &0.56 &0.678 &0.447 &0 &0.113\\ \hline 2020-白银 &0.939 &0.079 &0.975 &0.683 &0.925 &1 &0.983 &0.529 &0.945 &0.365 &0.8 &0.849 &0.529 &0.565 &0.852 &0.897 &0.81 &1 &0.961\\ \hline 2019-白银 &0.938 &0.052 &0.966 &0.868 &0.918 &1 &0.884 &0.573 &0.872 &0.297 &0.75 &0.877 &0.588 &0.563 &0.857 &0.874 &0.768 &1 &0.874\\ \hline 2018-白银 &0.937 &0.076 &0.669 &0.89 &0.973 &1 &0.875 &0.603 &0.872 &0.346 &0.775 &0.603 &0.588 &0.418 &0.853 &0.819 &0.762 &1 &0.881\\ \hline 2017-白银 &0.916 &0.132 &0.604 &0.874 &0.958 &1 &0.889 &0.625 &0.877 &0.381 &0.725 &0.562 &0.471 &0.419 &0.718 &0.625 &0.822 &1 &0.957\\ \hline 2016-白银 &0.936 &0.077 &0.605 &0.896 &0.964 &1 &0.89 &0.665 &0.88 &0.448 &0.75 &0.521 &0.824 &0.421 &0.794 &0.574 &0.278 &0.975 &0.948\\ \hline 2015-白银 &0.936 &0.075 &0.635 &0.907 &0.927 &1 &0.855 &0.606 &0.866 &0.333 &0.775 &0.247 &0.235 &0.433 &0.808 &0.584 &0.093 &0.962 &0.894\\ \hline 2014-白银 &0.938 &0.075 &0.64 &0.971 &0.871 &1 &0.463 &0.471 &0.74 &0 &0.875 &0.055 &0.118 &0.422 &0.798 &0.655 &0.085 &0.875 &0.881\\ \hline 2020-定西 &0.983 &0.145 &0.598 &0.528 &1 &1 &0.844 &0.809 &0.893 &0.619 &0.825 &1 &0.329 &1 &0.634 &1 &0.844 &1 &1\\ \hline 2019-定西 &0.985 &0.145 &0.588 &0.799 &0.979 &1 &0.845 &0.819 &0.894 &0.637 &0.8 &0.945 &0.506 &0.94 &0.524 &0.972 &0.758 &0.986 &0.995\\ \hline 2018-定西 &0.992 &0.136 &0.57 &0.764 &0.775 &1 &0.787 &0.832 &0.897 &0.669 &1 &0.616 &0.541 &0.94 &0.504 &0.846 &0.81 &0.986 &0.997\\ \hline 2017-定西 &0.992 &0.106 &0.564 &0.782 &0.77 &1 &0.833 &0.832 &0.879 &0.397 &0.675 &0.781 &0.4 &0.92 &0.478 &0.786 &0.739 &1 &0.987\\ \hline 2016-定西 &0.976 &0.062 &0.561 &0.8 &0.777 &1 &0.857 &0.799 &0.885 &0.663 &0.65 &0.726 &0.635 &0.92 &0.462 &0.778 &0.62 &1 &0.984\\ \hline 2015-定西 &0.979 &0.043 &0.555 &0.829 &0.748 &1 &0.849 &0.872 &0.889 &0.638 &0.825 &0.562 &0.341 &0.908 &0.462 &0.705 &0.581 &0.609 &0.966\\ \hline 2014-定西 &0.994 &0.015 &0.539 &0.967 &0.729 &1 &0.413 &0.811 &0.883 &0.638 &0.65 &0.479 &0.329 &0.494 &0.214 &0.685 &0.178 &0.546 &0.971\\ \hline 2020-临夏 &0.954 &0.062 &0.696 &0.572 &0.416 &1 &0.908 &0.68 &0.924 &0.504 &0.825 &0.973 &0.376 &0.916 &0.735 &0.766 &0.836 &1 &1\\ \hline 2019-临夏 &0.957 &0.056 &0.48 &0.87 &0.399 &1 &0.6 &0.956 &0.641 &0.918 &0.9 &0.918 &0.118 &0.122 &0.688 &0.723 &0.752 &0.967 &0.993\\ \hline 2018-临夏 &0.96 &0.048 &0.419 &0.88 &0.289 &1 &0.626 &0.964 &0.679 &0.931 &0.85 &0.616 &0 &0.11 &0 &0.703 &0.805 &0.983 &0.99\\ \hline 2017-临夏 &0.964 &0.048 &0.422 &0.906 &0.292 &1 &0.641 &0.969 &0.705 &0.942 &0.725 &0.644 &0.224 &0.117 &0 &0.577 &0.71 &1 &0.987\\ \hline 2016-临夏 &0.967 &0.043 &0.384 &0.918 &0.288 &1 &0.678 &0.978 &0.765 &0.963 &0.475 &0.616 &0.2 &0.099 &0.088 &0.675 &0.518 &0.619 &0.982\\ \hline 2015-临夏 &0.973 &0.037 &0.422 &0.933 &0.284 &1 &0.712 &0.986 &0.804 &0.986 &0.1 &0.425 &0.118 &0.106 &0.085 &0.416 &0 &0.884 &0.501\\ \hline 2014-临夏 &0.973 &0.035 &0.352 &0.997 &0.276 &1 &0.747 &1 &0.847 &1 &0.7 &0.438 &0.259 &0 &0.102 &0.302 &0.044 &0.806 &0.499\\ \hline 2020-西宁 &0.67 &0.571 &0.511 &0.288 &0.162 &0.617 &0.772 &0.749 &0.744 &0.777 &0.225 &0.767 &0.2 &0.654 &0.98 &0.849 &0.828 &0.984 &0.931\\ \hline 2019-西宁 &0.586 &0.577 &0.511 &0.355 &0.141 &0.469 &0.616 &0.703 &0.613 &0.758 &0.5 &0.918 &0.012 &0.626 &1 &0.967 &0.829 &0.953 &0.682\\ \hline 2018-西宁 &0.581 &0.524 &0.501 &0.426 &0.115 &0.533 &0.62 &0.667 &0.615 &0.471 &0.45 &0.507 &0.494 &0.631 &0.997 &0.474 &0.587 &0.939 &0.622\\ \hline 2017-西宁 &0.581 &0.504 &0.369 &0.495 &0.066 &0.591 &0.651 &0.682 &0.628 &0.494 &0.425 &0.37 &0.071 &0.629 &0.997 &0.572 &0.218 &0.937 &0.596\\ \hline 2016-西宁 &0.905 &0.488 &0.273 &0.576 &0.033 &0.666 &0.706 &0.698 &0.655 &0.521 &0.375 &0.178 &0.035 &0.596 &0.997 &0.428 &0.005 &0.92 &0.539\\ \hline 2015-西宁 &0.906 &0.57 &0.25 &0.652 &0.029 &0.861 &0.784 &0.7 &0.719 &0.485 &0.475 &0.274 &0.082 &0.596 &0.997 &0.484 &0.142 &0.941 &0.142\\ \hline 2014-西宁 &0.908 &0.569 &0.238 &0.696 &0 &0.869 &0.833 &0.737 &0.73 &0.562 &0.4 &0.082 &0.024 &0.596 &0.98 &0.37 &0.098 &0.928 &0\\ \hline 2020-海东 &1 &0.034 &0.283 &0.882 &0.907 &1 &1 &0.881 &1 &0.845 &0.525 &0.877 &0.153 &0.152 &0.835 &0.922 &0.859 &0.953 &0.765\\ \hline 2019-海东 &0.985 &0.052 &0.431 &0.902 &0.905 &1 &0.874 &0.827 &0.965 &0.821 &0.425 &0.904 &0.494 &0.141 &0.812 &0.972 &0.809 &0.954 &0.681\\ \hline 2018-海东 &0.961 &0.062 &0.26 &0.916 &0.898 &1 &0.874 &0.862 &0.968 &0.84 &0.45 &0.562 &1 &0.134 &0.766 &0.63 &0.557 &0.941 &0.567\\ \hline 2017-海东 &0.987 &0.055 &0.222 &0.941 &0.577 &1 &0.885 &0.877 &0.972 &0.857 &0.525 &0.301 &0.471 &0.134 &0.714 &0.539 &0.473 &0.907 &0.544\\ \hline 2016-海东 &0.987 &0.055 &0.202 &0.971 &0.577 &1 &0.894 &0.886 &0.977 &0.871 &0.4 &0.164 &0.447 &0.092 &0.669 &0.458 &0.416 &0.921 &0.526\\ \hline 2015-海东 &0.991 &0.013 &0.102 &0.968 &0.537 &1 &0.889 &0.922 &0.875 &0.835 &0.45 &0.301 &0.294 &0.085 &0.623 &0.375 &1 &0.902 &0.1\\ \hline 2014-海东 &0.995 &0 &0 &1 &0.503 &1 &0.908 &0.935 &0.894 &0.86 &0.375 &0.178 &0.059 &0.063 &0.685 &0.358 &1 &0.636 &0.17\\ \hline \end{array} $$
正极值点构成
$$ \begin{array}{c|c|c|c|c|c|c}{M_{1 \times19}} & -A1 & +A2 & +A3 & -A4 & +B1 & -B2 & -B3 & -B4 & -B5 & -B6 & -C1 & -C2 & -C3 & +C4 & +C5 & +C6 & +C7 & +C8 & -C9\\ \hline \mathbf{Zone^+} &1 &1 &1 &1 &1 &1 &1 &1 &1 &1 &1 &1 &1 &1 &1 &1 &1 &1 &1\\ \hline \end{array} $$
负极值点构成
$$ \begin{array}{c|c|c|c|c|c|c}{M_{1 \times19}} & -A1 & +A2 & +A3 & -A4 & +B1 & -B2 & -B3 & -B4 & -B5 & -B6 & -C1 & -C2 & -C3 & +C4 & +C5 & +C6 & +C7 & +C8 & -C9\\ \hline \mathbf{Zone^-} &0 &0 &0 &0 &0 &0 &0 &0 &0 &0 &0 &0 &0 &0 &0 &0 &0 &0 &0\\ \hline \end{array} $$

采用的是熵权法(EWM)求权重


$$ \begin{array}{c|c|c|c|c|c|c}{M_{2 \times19}} & -A1 & +A2 & +A3 & -A4 & +B1 & -B2 & -B3 & -B4 & -B5 & -B6 & -C1 & -C2 & -C3 & +C4 & +C5 & +C6 & +C7 & +C8 & -C9\\ \hline EWM所得权重 &0.0475 &0.1999 &0.0375 &0.0359 &0.0623 &0.0293 &0.0364 &0.0211 &0.0348 &0.0453 &0.0531 &0.058 &0.0871 &0.0718 &0.0427 &0.0247 &0.0569 &0.0212 &0.0345\\ \hline 权重大小顺序 &8 &1 &11 &13 &4 &16 &12 &19 &14 &9 &7 &5 &2 &3 &10 &17 &6 &18 &15\\ \hline \end{array} $$

子系统的期望综合值U_S的计算,与子系统的遗憾综合值U_R的计算


总共有2个子系统


子系统1原始数据如下


$$ \begin{array}{c|c|c|c|c|c|c}{M_{42 \times10}} &-A1 &+A2 &+A3 &-A4 &+B1 &-B2 &-B3 &-B4 &-B5 &-B6\\ \hline 2020-兰州 &163.54 &3189 &21.95 &96.92 &9744 &1112.7 &5977.36 &14861.55 &36.61 &226.19\\ \hline 2019-兰州 &214.61 &3109 &21.54 &92.49 &8357.78 &1530 &7980.41 &14121.83 &42.92 &218.22\\ \hline 2018-兰州 &218.44 &3319 &21.51 &88.14 &8146.03 &1386 &8328.64 &13518.82 &70.44 &201.89\\ \hline 2017-兰州 &223.98 &2801 &17.56 &83.16 &7847.49 &1291.64 &7684.69 &12882.39 &69.94 &173.98\\ \hline 2016-兰州 &219.68 &2800 &17.02 &73.14 &7993.44 &1089 &6950.64 &12208.84 &66.04 &148.45\\ \hline 2015-兰州 &205.49 &2739 &16.11 &62.51 &7750.79 &809 &6153.3 &11801.02 &62.61 &127.11\\ \hline 2014-兰州 &212.81 &2769 &16.56 &52.42 &7729.49 &700 &7600 &20100 &59.29 &103.36\\ \hline 2020-白银 &14.54 &317 &21.47 &40.2 &12172.25 &0 &1134 &10144 &7.86 &150\\ \hline 2019-白银 &14.78 &226 &21.3 &24.79 &12117.65 &0 &1864.83 &9312.1 &12.73 &164.44\\ \hline 2018-白银 &15.01 &306 &15.55 &22.98 &12579.26 &0 &1924 &8743.72 &12.73 &153.97\\ \hline 2017-白银 &19.7 &490 &14.3 &24.33 &12453.48 &0 &1824.54 &8343.25 &12.4 &146.64\\ \hline 2016-白银 &15.19 &310 &14.31 &22.46 &12502.5 &0 &1817.63 &7583.39 &12.15 &132.43\\ \hline 2015-白银 &15.17 &303 &14.9 &21.55 &12190.84 &0 &2071 &8689 &13.1 &156.67\\ \hline 2014-白银 &14.89 &303 &15 &16.29 &11714.9 &0 &4941 &11235 &21.42 &227.47\\ \hline 2020-定西 &4.69 &532 &14.17 &53.1 &12808 &0 &2152 &4874 &11.3 &96.09\\ \hline 2019-定西 &4.23 &532 &13.98 &30.58 &12626.64 &0 &2147.44 &4684.77 &11.27 &92.19\\ \hline 2018-定西 &2.78 &500 &13.63 &33.43 &10904.5 &0 &2568.42 &4430.35 &11.02 &85.48\\ \hline 2017-定西 &2.86 &403 &13.52 &31.99 &10862.83 &0 &2233.75 &4433.87 &12.23 &143.25\\ \hline 2016-定西 &6.4 &260 &13.47 &30.48 &10922.02 &0 &2059.84 &5055.9 &11.84 &86.64\\ \hline 2015-定西 &5.7 &198 &13.35 &28.09 &10670.23 &0 &2118.56 &3690.33 &11.6 &92\\ \hline 2014-定西 &2.39 &108 &13.03 &16.62 &10514.99 &0 &5306 &4830 &11.99 &92.1\\ \hline 2020-临夏 &11.2 &261 &16.07 &49.4 &7859.24 &0 &1687 &7305 &9.28 &120.53\\ \hline 2019-临夏 &10.6 &242 &11.89 &24.69 &7720.74 &0 &3938 &2106 &28 &32.64\\ \hline 2018-临夏 &9.9 &214 &10.71 &23.84 &6790.23 &0 &3750 &1949.6 &25.46 &29.68\\ \hline 2017-临夏 &9.1 &216 &10.77 &21.69 &6817.37 &0 &3641 &1856.8 &23.79 &27.48\\ \hline 2016-临夏 &8.3 &197 &10.04 &20.71 &6781.12 &0 &3371 &1688 &19.82 &22.9\\ \hline 2015-临夏 &7.1 &180 &10.77 &19.43 &6749.12 &0 &3122 &1532 &17.21 &18.15\\ \hline 2014-临夏 &6.9 &173 &9.42 &14.15 &6681.08 &0 &2865 &1276.7 &14.34 &15.13\\ \hline 2020-西宁 &74.6 &1920 &12.5 &73.03 &5715 &586.2 &2680.8 &5998.5 &21.15 &62.46\\ \hline 2019-西宁 &93.28 &1940 &12.5 &67.4 &5532 &812.6 &3823.7 &6861.2 &29.84 &66.57\\ \hline 2018-西宁 &94.52 &1767 &12.3 &61.51 &5317 &715 &3793.8 &7548.6 &29.71 &127.53\\ \hline 2017-西宁 &94.35 &1703 &9.75 &55.81 &4903 &625.5 &3564 &7268 &28.83 &122.61\\ \hline 2016-西宁 &22.13 &1648 &7.89 &49.11 &4622 &510.7 &3165.7 &6952.6 &27.05 &116.77\\ \hline 2015-西宁 &22.01 &1918 &7.46 &42.8 &4585 &212 &2592 &6923 &22.84 &124.53\\ \hline 2014-西宁 &21.49 &1915 &7.23 &39.12 &4341 &201 &2232 &6221 &22.08 &108.22\\ \hline 2020-海东 &0.98 &170 &8.1 &23.69 &12024 &0 &1013 &3520 &4.23 &48.13\\ \hline 2019-海东 &4.29 &227 &10.95 &21.96 &12000.07 &0 &1932 &4538 &6.58 &53.21\\ \hline 2018-海东 &9.71 &259 &7.65 &20.87 &11946.1 &0 &1938 &3883.52 &6.37 &49.04\\ \hline 2017-海东 &3.97 &236 &6.91 &18.79 &9229.4 &0 &1854.63 &3600.65 &6.11 &45.47\\ \hline 2016-海东 &3.97 &236 &6.52 &16.25 &9229.4 &0 &1789.26 &3414.15 &5.73 &42.46\\ \hline 2015-海东 &2.98 &100 &4.6 &16.49 &8887.86 &0 &1825.53 &2748.52 &12.48 &50.12\\ \hline 2014-海东 &2.01 &58 &2.62 &13.86 &8599 &0 &1682.82 &2494.03 &11.25 &44.95\\ \hline \end{array} $$

子系统2原始数据如下


$$ \begin{array}{c|c|c|c|c|c|c}{M_{42 \times9}} &-C1 &-C2 &-C3 &+C4 &+C5 &+C6 &+C7 &+C8 &-C9\\ \hline 2020-兰州 &47 &76 &68.8 &13.19 &33.14 &85.2 &96.38 &99.9 &6732\\ \hline 2019-兰州 &50 &79 &69 &13.45 &38.55 &81.1 &97.7 &99.5 &24879\\ \hline 2018-兰州 &55 &103 &68 &13.89 &32.03 &58.4 &96 &99.39 &19986\\ \hline 2017-兰州 &57 &111 &68.1 &12.76 &30.93 &63.6 &95.49 &100 &15786\\ \hline 2016-兰州 &57 &115 &68.2 &12.71 &27.4 &89.6 &95.72 &40.4 &15892\\ \hline 2015-兰州 &53 &120 &68.8 &9.17 &25.8 &88.3 &88.96 &19.65 &45209\\ \hline 2014-兰州 &48 &126 &67 &11.49 &28 &85.3 &83.51 &19.15 &63801\\ \hline 2020-白银 &25 &64 &65.5 &11.56 &36.34 &94 &94.35 &100 &4959\\ \hline 2019-白银 &27 &62 &65 &11.54 &36.48 &93.1 &93.1 &100 &10961\\ \hline 2018-白银 &26 &82 &65 &9.49 &36.39 &90.9 &92.9 &100 &10511\\ \hline 2017-白银 &28 &85 &66 &9.51 &32.51 &83.2 &94.69 &100 &5264\\ \hline 2016-白银 &27 &88 &63 &9.54 &34.7 &81.2 &78.48 &97.96 &5823\\ \hline 2015-白银 &26 &108 &68 &9.71 &35.1 &81.6 &72.98 &96.95 &9594\\ \hline 2014-白银 &22 &122 &69 &9.55 &34.8 &84.4 &72.74 &89.88 &10486\\ \hline 2020-定西 &24 &53 &67.2 &17.69 &30.1 &98.1 &95.34 &100 &2248\\ \hline 2019-定西 &25 &57 &65.7 &16.85 &26.97 &97 &92.8 &98.9 &2618\\ \hline 2018-定西 &17 &81 &65.4 &16.85 &26.4 &92 &94.34 &98.87 &2468\\ \hline 2017-定西 &30 &69 &66.6 &16.56 &25.66 &89.6 &92.22 &100 &3141\\ \hline 2016-定西 &31 &73 &64.6 &16.56 &25.2 &89.3 &88.69 &100 &3374\\ \hline 2015-定西 &24 &85 &67.1 &16.39 &25.2 &86.4 &87.5 &68.39 &4612\\ \hline 2014-定西 &31 &91 &67.2 &10.56 &18.1 &85.6 &75.51 &63.27 &4231\\ \hline 2020-临夏 &24 &55 &66.8 &16.51 &33 &88.8 &95.1 &100 &2263\\ \hline 2019-临夏 &21 &59 &69 &5.33 &31.66 &87.1 &92.6 &97.3 &2732\\ \hline 2018-临夏 &23 &81 &70 &5.16 &11.98 &86.3 &94.2 &98.65 &2923\\ \hline 2017-临夏 &28 &79 &68.1 &5.26 &11.98 &81.3 &91.36 &100 &3158\\ \hline 2016-临夏 &38 &81 &68.3 &5 &14.5 &85.2 &85.63 &69.16 &3485\\ \hline 2015-临夏 &53 &95 &69 &5.1 &14.4 &74.9 &70.2 &90.6 &36851\\ \hline 2014-临夏 &29 &94 &67.8 &3.61 &14.9 &70.4 &71.5 &84.3 &37026\\ \hline 2020-西宁 &48 &70 &68.3 &12.82 &40.02 &92.1 &94.87 &98.73 &7008\\ \hline 2019-西宁 &37 &59 &69.9 &12.42 &40.58 &96.8 &94.91 &96.19 &24338\\ \hline 2018-西宁 &39 &89 &65.8 &12.5 &40.5 &77.2 &87.7 &95.1 &28456\\ \hline 2017-西宁 &40 &99 &69.4 &12.47 &40.5 &81.1 &76.7 &94.91 &30254\\ \hline 2016-西宁 &42 &113 &69.7 &12 &40.5 &75.4 &70.36 &93.51 &34251\\ \hline 2015-西宁 &38 &106 &69.3 &12 &40.5 &77.6 &74.44 &95.27 &61783\\ \hline 2014-西宁 &41 &120 &69.8 &12 &40 &73.1 &73.12 &94.16 &71622\\ \hline 2020-海东 &36 &62 &68.7 &5.75 &35.86 &95 &95.81 &96.2 &18581\\ \hline 2019-海东 &40 &60 &65.8 &5.6 &35.2 &97 &94.3 &96.31 &24365\\ \hline 2018-海东 &39 &85 &61.5 &5.5 &33.9 &83.4 &86.8 &95.24 &32314\\ \hline 2017-海东 &36 &104 &66 &5.5 &32.4 &79.8 &84.3 &92.5 &33912\\ \hline 2016-海东 &41 &114 &66.2 &4.9 &31.12 &76.6 &82.6 &93.6 &35127\\ \hline 2015-海东 &39 &104 &67.5 &4.8 &29.79 &73.3 &100 &92.1 &64696\\ \hline 2014-海东 &42 &113 &69.5 &4.5 &31.56 &72.6 &100 &70.6 &59817\\ \hline \end{array} $$

子系统1归一化矩阵如下


$$ \begin{array}{c|c|c|c|c|c|c}{M_{42 \times10}} &-A1 &+A2 &+A3 &-A4 &+B1 &-B2 &-B3 &-B4 &-B5 &-B6\\ \hline 2020-兰州 &0.27103 &0.96013 &1 &0 &0.63812 &0.27275 &0.3214 &0.2783 &0.51095 &0.00603\\ \hline 2019-兰州 &0.04202 &0.9356 &0.97879 &0.05333 &0.4744 &0 &0.0476 &0.31759 &0.41565 &0.04356\\ \hline 2018-兰州 &0.02484 &1 &0.97724 &0.10571 &0.4494 &0.09412 &0 &0.34963 &0 &0.12047\\ \hline 2017-兰州 &0 &0.84115 &0.77289 &0.16566 &0.41414 &0.15579 &0.08802 &0.38344 &0.00755 &0.25191\\ \hline 2016-兰州 &0.01928 &0.84085 &0.74496 &0.2863 &0.43137 &0.28824 &0.18836 &0.41922 &0.06646 &0.37214\\ \hline 2015-兰州 &0.08291 &0.82214 &0.69788 &0.41428 &0.40272 &0.47124 &0.29735 &0.44089 &0.11826 &0.47264\\ \hline 2014-兰州 &0.05009 &0.83134 &0.72116 &0.53576 &0.4002 &0.54248 &0.0996 &0 &0.1684 &0.58449\\ \hline 2020-白银 &0.93919 &0.07942 &0.97517 &0.68288 &0.92491 &1 &0.98346 &0.52892 &0.94517 &0.36484\\ \hline 2019-白银 &0.93812 &0.05152 &0.96637 &0.86841 &0.91847 &1 &0.88356 &0.57311 &0.87162 &0.29684\\ \hline 2018-白银 &0.93709 &0.07605 &0.66891 &0.8902 &0.97298 &1 &0.87547 &0.60331 &0.87162 &0.34614\\ \hline 2017-白银 &0.91605 &0.13247 &0.60424 &0.87395 &0.95813 &1 &0.88907 &0.62458 &0.8766 &0.38066\\ \hline 2016-白银 &0.93628 &0.07728 &0.60476 &0.89646 &0.96392 &1 &0.89001 &0.66495 &0.88038 &0.44758\\ \hline 2015-白银 &0.93637 &0.07513 &0.63528 &0.90742 &0.92711 &1 &0.85538 &0.60622 &0.86603 &0.33343\\ \hline 2014-白银 &0.93762 &0.07513 &0.64046 &0.97074 &0.8709 &1 &0.46307 &0.47096 &0.74037 &0\\ \hline 2020-定西 &0.98336 &0.14535 &0.59752 &0.52757 &1 &1 &0.84431 &0.80889 &0.89322 &0.61872\\ \hline 2019-定西 &0.98543 &0.14535 &0.58769 &0.7987 &0.97858 &1 &0.84493 &0.81894 &0.89367 &0.63709\\ \hline 2018-定西 &0.99193 &0.13554 &0.56958 &0.76439 &0.77519 &1 &0.78738 &0.83246 &0.89745 &0.66869\\ \hline 2017-定西 &0.99157 &0.1058 &0.56389 &0.78172 &0.77026 &1 &0.83313 &0.83227 &0.87917 &0.39663\\ \hline 2016-定西 &0.9757 &0.06194 &0.5613 &0.7999 &0.77726 &1 &0.8569 &0.79923 &0.88506 &0.66323\\ \hline 2015-定西 &0.97883 &0.04293 &0.5551 &0.82868 &0.74752 &1 &0.84888 &0.87177 &0.88869 &0.63799\\ \hline 2014-定西 &0.99368 &0.01533 &0.53854 &0.96677 &0.72918 &1 &0.41318 &0.81123 &0.8828 &0.63752\\ \hline 2020-临夏 &0.95417 &0.06225 &0.69581 &0.57212 &0.41552 &1 &0.90787 &0.67974 &0.92373 &0.50363\\ \hline 2019-临夏 &0.95686 &0.05642 &0.47957 &0.86961 &0.39917 &1 &0.60017 &0.95594 &0.64099 &0.91754\\ \hline 2018-临夏 &0.96 &0.04784 &0.41852 &0.87985 &0.28927 &1 &0.62587 &0.96425 &0.67935 &0.93148\\ \hline 2017-临夏 &0.96359 &0.04845 &0.42162 &0.90573 &0.29247 &1 &0.64077 &0.96918 &0.70458 &0.94184\\ \hline 2016-临夏 &0.96717 &0.04262 &0.38386 &0.91753 &0.28819 &1 &0.67768 &0.97815 &0.76454 &0.96341\\ \hline 2015-临夏 &0.97256 &0.03741 &0.42162 &0.93294 &0.28441 &1 &0.71171 &0.98644 &0.80396 &0.98578\\ \hline 2014-临夏 &0.97345 &0.03527 &0.35178 &0.99651 &0.27638 &1 &0.74684 &1 &0.8473 &1\\ \hline 2020-西宁 &0.66987 &0.57099 &0.51112 &0.28762 &0.16228 &0.61686 &0.77202 &0.74915 &0.74445 &0.7771\\ \hline 2019-西宁 &0.5861 &0.57712 &0.51112 &0.35541 &0.14066 &0.46889 &0.6158 &0.70332 &0.6132 &0.75775\\ \hline 2018-西宁 &0.58054 &0.52407 &0.50078 &0.42632 &0.11527 &0.53268 &0.61988 &0.6668 &0.61516 &0.47066\\ \hline 2017-西宁 &0.5813 &0.50445 &0.36886 &0.49494 &0.06638 &0.59118 &0.6513 &0.68171 &0.62845 &0.49383\\ \hline 2016-西宁 &0.90516 &0.48758 &0.27263 &0.57561 &0.03319 &0.66621 &0.70574 &0.69846 &0.65534 &0.52133\\ \hline 2015-西宁 &0.9057 &0.57038 &0.25039 &0.65158 &0.02882 &0.86144 &0.78416 &0.70004 &0.71892 &0.48479\\ \hline 2014-西宁 &0.90803 &0.56946 &0.23849 &0.69588 &0 &0.86863 &0.83337 &0.73733 &0.7304 &0.5616\\ \hline 2020-海东 &1 &0.03435 &0.2835 &0.88165 &0.90741 &1 &1 &0.88082 &1 &0.84459\\ \hline 2019-海东 &0.98516 &0.05182 &0.43094 &0.90248 &0.90458 &1 &0.87438 &0.82674 &0.96451 &0.82066\\ \hline 2018-海东 &0.96085 &0.06164 &0.26022 &0.9156 &0.8982 &1 &0.87356 &0.86151 &0.96768 &0.8403\\ \hline 2017-海东 &0.98659 &0.05458 &0.22193 &0.94065 &0.57735 &1 &0.88495 &0.87654 &0.97161 &0.85712\\ \hline 2016-海东 &0.98659 &0.05458 &0.20176 &0.97123 &0.57735 &1 &0.89389 &0.88645 &0.97734 &0.87129\\ \hline 2015-海东 &0.99103 &0.01288 &0.10243 &0.96834 &0.53701 &1 &0.88893 &0.92181 &0.8754 &0.83522\\ \hline 2014-海东 &0.99538 &0 &0 &1 &0.50289 &1 &0.90844 &0.93533 &0.89397 &0.85956\\ \hline \end{array} $$

子系统2归一化矩阵如下


$$ \begin{array}{c|c|c|c|c|c|c}{M_{42 \times9}} &-C1 &-C2 &-C3 &+C4 &+C5 &+C6 &+C7 &+C8 &-C9\\ \hline 2020-兰州 &0.25 &0.68493 &0.14118 &0.6804 &0.73986 &0.67506 &0.87852 &0.99876 &0.93536\\ \hline 2019-兰州 &0.175 &0.64384 &0.11765 &0.69886 &0.92902 &0.57179 &0.92282 &0.99382 &0.67378\\ \hline 2018-兰州 &0.05 &0.31507 &0.23529 &0.73011 &0.70105 &0 &0.86577 &0.99246 &0.74431\\ \hline 2017-兰州 &0 &0.20548 &0.22353 &0.64986 &0.66259 &0.13098 &0.84866 &1 &0.80485\\ \hline 2016-兰州 &0 &0.15068 &0.21176 &0.64631 &0.53916 &0.78589 &0.85638 &0.26283 &0.80333\\ \hline 2015-兰州 &0.1 &0.08219 &0.14118 &0.39489 &0.48322 &0.75315 &0.62953 &0.00618 &0.38073\\ \hline 2014-兰州 &0.225 &0 &0.35294 &0.55966 &0.56014 &0.67758 &0.44664 &0 &0.11274\\ \hline 2020-白银 &0.8 &0.84932 &0.52941 &0.56463 &0.85175 &0.89673 &0.8104 &1 &0.96092\\ \hline 2019-白银 &0.75 &0.87671 &0.58824 &0.56321 &0.85664 &0.87406 &0.76846 &1 &0.87441\\ \hline 2018-白银 &0.775 &0.60274 &0.58824 &0.41761 &0.8535 &0.81864 &0.76174 &1 &0.88089\\ \hline 2017-白银 &0.725 &0.56164 &0.47059 &0.41903 &0.71783 &0.62469 &0.82181 &1 &0.95653\\ \hline 2016-白银 &0.75 &0.52055 &0.82353 &0.42116 &0.79441 &0.57431 &0.27785 &0.97477 &0.94847\\ \hline 2015-白银 &0.775 &0.24658 &0.23529 &0.43324 &0.80839 &0.58438 &0.09329 &0.96228 &0.89411\\ \hline 2014-白银 &0.875 &0.05479 &0.11765 &0.42188 &0.7979 &0.65491 &0.08523 &0.87483 &0.88125\\ \hline 2020-定西 &0.825 &1 &0.32941 &1 &0.63357 &1 &0.84362 &1 &1\\ \hline 2019-定西 &0.8 &0.94521 &0.50588 &0.94034 &0.52413 &0.97229 &0.75839 &0.98639 &0.99467\\ \hline 2018-定西 &1 &0.61644 &0.54118 &0.94034 &0.5042 &0.84635 &0.81007 &0.98602 &0.99683\\ \hline 2017-定西 &0.675 &0.78082 &0.4 &0.91974 &0.47832 &0.78589 &0.73893 &1 &0.98713\\ \hline 2016-定西 &0.65 &0.72603 &0.63529 &0.91974 &0.46224 &0.77834 &0.62047 &1 &0.98377\\ \hline 2015-定西 &0.825 &0.56164 &0.34118 &0.90767 &0.46224 &0.70529 &0.58054 &0.60903 &0.96592\\ \hline 2014-定西 &0.65 &0.47945 &0.32941 &0.49361 &0.21399 &0.68514 &0.17819 &0.5457 &0.97142\\ \hline 2020-临夏 &0.825 &0.9726 &0.37647 &0.91619 &0.73497 &0.76574 &0.83557 &1 &0.99978\\ \hline 2019-临夏 &0.9 &0.91781 &0.11765 &0.12216 &0.68811 &0.72292 &0.75168 &0.9666 &0.99302\\ \hline 2018-临夏 &0.85 &0.61644 &0 &0.11009 &0 &0.70277 &0.80537 &0.9833 &0.99027\\ \hline 2017-临夏 &0.725 &0.64384 &0.22353 &0.11719 &0 &0.57683 &0.71007 &1 &0.98688\\ \hline 2016-临夏 &0.475 &0.61644 &0.2 &0.09872 &0.08811 &0.67506 &0.51779 &0.61855 &0.98217\\ \hline 2015-临夏 &0.1 &0.42466 &0.11765 &0.10582 &0.08462 &0.41562 &0 &0.88374 &0.50121\\ \hline 2014-临夏 &0.7 &0.43836 &0.25882 &0 &0.1021 &0.30227 &0.04362 &0.80581 &0.49869\\ \hline 2020-西宁 &0.225 &0.76712 &0.2 &0.65412 &0.98042 &0.84887 &0.82785 &0.98429 &0.93139\\ \hline 2019-西宁 &0.5 &0.91781 &0.01176 &0.62571 &1 &0.96725 &0.82919 &0.95288 &0.68158\\ \hline 2018-西宁 &0.45 &0.50685 &0.49412 &0.63139 &0.9972 &0.47355 &0.58725 &0.93939 &0.62222\\ \hline 2017-西宁 &0.425 &0.36986 &0.07059 &0.62926 &0.9972 &0.57179 &0.21812 &0.93704 &0.5963\\ \hline 2016-西宁 &0.375 &0.17808 &0.03529 &0.59588 &0.9972 &0.42821 &0.00537 &0.91973 &0.53869\\ \hline 2015-西宁 &0.475 &0.27397 &0.08235 &0.59588 &0.9972 &0.48363 &0.14228 &0.9415 &0.14183\\ \hline 2014-西宁 &0.4 &0.08219 &0.02353 &0.59588 &0.97972 &0.37028 &0.09799 &0.92777 &0\\ \hline 2020-海东 &0.525 &0.87671 &0.15294 &0.15199 &0.83497 &0.92191 &0.8594 &0.953 &0.76457\\ \hline 2019-海东 &0.425 &0.90411 &0.49412 &0.14134 &0.81189 &0.97229 &0.80872 &0.95436 &0.68119\\ \hline 2018-海东 &0.45 &0.56164 &1 &0.13423 &0.76643 &0.62972 &0.55705 &0.94113 &0.56661\\ \hline 2017-海东 &0.525 &0.30137 &0.47059 &0.13423 &0.71399 &0.53904 &0.47315 &0.90724 &0.54358\\ \hline 2016-海东 &0.4 &0.16438 &0.44706 &0.09162 &0.66923 &0.45844 &0.41611 &0.92084 &0.52606\\ \hline 2015-海东 &0.45 &0.30137 &0.29412 &0.08452 &0.62273 &0.37531 &1 &0.90229 &0.09984\\ \hline 2014-海东 &0.375 &0.17808 &0.05882 &0.06321 &0.68462 &0.35768 &1 &0.63636 &0.17016\\ \hline \end{array} $$

子系统的权重分别计算出


子系统1的权重


$$ \begin{array}{c|c|c|c|c|c|c}{M_{2 \times10}} &-A1 &+A2 &+A3 &-A4 &+B1 &-B2 &-B3 &-B4 &-B5 &-B6\\ \hline 权重 &0.08629273 &0.36339171 &0.06817385 &0.06535056 &0.11330688 &0.05320386 &0.06622993 &0.03841711 &0.06323168 &0.0824017\\ \hline 权重大小顺序 &3 &1 &5 &7 &2 &9 &6 &10 &8 &4\\ \hline \end{array} $$

子系统2的权重


$$ \begin{array}{c|c|c|c|c|c|c}{M_{2 \times9}} &-C1 &-C2 &-C3 &+C4 &+C5 &+C6 &+C7 &+C8 &-C9\\ \hline 权重 &0.11802571 &0.12879662 &0.19360999 &0.15959921 &0.09485192 &0.0548334 &0.12635324 &0.04720417 &0.07672574\\ \hline 权重大小顺序 &5 &3 &1 &2 &6 &8 &4 &9 &7\\ \hline \end{array} $$

子系统综合评价值计算公式


$$期望综合值 US_i = \sum_\limits{j=1}^m{ \omega_{j} \left(\frac{ n_{ij}-Min(n_j)}{Max(n_j) -Min(n_j)} \right)} \quad \quad $$ $$遗憾综合值 UR_i = \max_\limits{j} { \left( \omega_{j} (\frac{n_{ij}-Min(n_j)}{Max(n_j) -Min(n_j)} )\right)} \quad \quad $$

子系统1的两组综合值


$$\begin{array}{c|c|c|c|c|c|c}{M_{42 \times2}} &期望综合值US &遗憾综合值UR\\ \hline 2020-兰州 &0.592 &0.349\\ \hline 2019-兰州 &0.513 &0.34\\ \hline 2018-兰州 &0.518 &0.363\\ \hline 2017-兰州 &0.466 &0.306\\ \hline 2016-兰州 &0.504 &0.306\\ \hline 2015-兰州 &0.534 &0.299\\ \hline 2014-兰州 &0.53 &0.302\\ \hline 2020-白银 &0.554 &0.105\\ \hline 2019-白银 &0.54 &0.104\\ \hline 2018-白银 &0.541 &0.11\\ \hline 2017-白银 &0.557 &0.109\\ \hline 2016-白银 &0.548 &0.109\\ \hline 2015-白银 &0.531 &0.105\\ \hline 2014-白银 &0.463 &0.099\\ \hline 2020-定西 &0.574 &0.113\\ \hline 2019-定西 &0.591 &0.111\\ \hline 2018-定西 &0.561 &0.088\\ \hline 2017-定西 &0.529 &0.087\\ \hline 2016-定西 &0.537 &0.088\\ \hline 2015-定西 &0.528 &0.085\\ \hline 2014-定西 &0.494 &0.086\\ \hline 2020-临夏 &0.476 &0.082\\ \hline 2019-临夏 &0.484 &0.083\\ \hline 2018-临夏 &0.47 &0.083\\ \hline 2017-临夏 &0.477 &0.083\\ \hline 2016-临夏 &0.481 &0.083\\ \hline 2015-临夏 &0.49 &0.084\\ \hline 2014-临夏 &0.494 &0.084\\ \hline 2020-西宁 &0.561 &0.207\\ \hline 2019-西宁 &0.528 &0.21\\ \hline 2018-西宁 &0.488 &0.19\\ \hline 2017-西宁 &0.48 &0.183\\ \hline 2016-西宁 &0.509 &0.177\\ \hline 2015-西宁 &0.558 &0.207\\ \hline 2014-西宁 &0.569 &0.207\\ \hline 2020-海东 &0.565 &0.103\\ \hline 2019-海东 &0.566 &0.102\\ \hline 2018-海东 &0.559 &0.102\\ \hline 2017-海东 &0.525 &0.085\\ \hline 2016-海东 &0.528 &0.085\\ \hline 2015-海东 &0.493 &0.086\\ \hline 2014-海东 &0.485 &0.086\\ \hline \end{array} $$

子系统2的两组综合值


$$\begin{array}{c|c|c|c|c|c|c}{M_{42 \times2}} &期望综合值US &遗憾综合值UR\\ \hline 2020-兰州 &0.591 &0.111\\ \hline 2019-兰州 &0.573 &0.117\\ \hline 2018-兰州 &0.488 &0.117\\ \hline 2017-兰州 &0.46 &0.107\\ \hline 2016-兰州 &0.44 &0.108\\ \hline 2015-兰州 &0.309 &0.08\\ \hline 2014-兰州 &0.34 &0.089\\ \hline 2020-白银 &0.75 &0.109\\ \hline 2019-白银 &0.746 &0.114\\ \hline 2018-白银 &0.687 &0.114\\ \hline 2017-白银 &0.643 &0.104\\ \hline 2016-白银 &0.643 &0.159\\ \hline 2015-白银 &0.472 &0.091\\ \hline 2014-白银 &0.432 &0.103\\ \hline 2020-定西 &0.795 &0.16\\ \hline 2019-定西 &0.786 &0.15\\ \hline 2018-定西 &0.772 &0.15\\ \hline 2017-定西 &0.709 &0.147\\ \hline 2016-定西 &0.728 &0.147\\ \hline 2015-定西 &0.639 &0.145\\ \hline 2014-定西 &0.462 &0.079\\ \hline 2020-临夏 &0.783 &0.146\\ \hline 2019-临夏 &0.588 &0.118\\ \hline 2018-临夏 &0.46 &0.102\\ \hline 2017-临夏 &0.475 &0.09\\ \hline 2016-临夏 &0.405 &0.079\\ \hline 2015-临夏 &0.217 &0.055\\ \hline 2014-临夏 &0.297 &0.083\\ \hline 2020-西宁 &0.631 &0.105\\ \hline 2019-西宁 &0.629 &0.118\\ \hline 2018-西宁 &0.602 &0.101\\ \hline 2017-西宁 &0.455 &0.1\\ \hline 2016-西宁 &0.373 &0.095\\ \hline 2015-西宁 &0.397 &0.095\\ \hline 2014-西宁 &0.327 &0.095\\ \hline 2020-海东 &0.571 &0.113\\ \hline 2019-海东 &0.615 &0.116\\ \hline 2018-海东 &0.606 &0.194\\ \hline 2017-海东 &0.455 &0.091\\ \hline 2016-海东 &0.395 &0.087\\ \hline 2015-海东 &0.419 &0.126\\ \hline 2014-海东 &0.343 &0.126\\ \hline \end{array} $$

两组协调度的计算


    耦合度公式 $$ C=\left( \frac{\prod \limits_{i=1}^{n} U_i } { \left( \frac{1}{n}\sum \limits_{i=1}^{n}{U_i} \right )^n } \right ) ^\frac{1}{n} $$

    子系统数目为n

    n=2

$$ C=\frac{2\sqrt{U_1U_2}}{U_1+U_2} $$

    n=3

 $$ C=\frac{3 \left ({U_1U_2U_3} \right )^ {\frac{1}{3}} }{U_1+U_2+U_3}=\frac{3 \sqrt[3] {U_1U_2U_3} }{U_1+U_2+U_3} $$

    n=4

 $$ C=\frac{4 \left ({U_1U_2U_3U_4} \right )^ {\frac{1}{4}} }{U_1+U_2+U_3+U_4}=\frac{4 \sqrt[4] {U_1U_2U_3U_4} }{U_1+U_2+U_3+U_4} $$

   协调发展度公式 $$ D=\sqrt{CT} $$

    $$ T=\sum \limits_{i=1}^{n}{\omega _i U_i} $$

期望综合值US


$$综合值=\begin{array}{c|c|c|c|c|c|c}{M_{42 \times2}} &子系统1 &子系统2\\ \hline 2020-兰州 &0.592061 &0.590753\\ \hline 2019-兰州 &0.512804 &0.572572\\ \hline 2018-兰州 &0.518347 &0.488402\\ \hline 2017-兰州 &0.466189 &0.459673\\ \hline 2016-兰州 &0.504372 &0.440035\\ \hline 2015-兰州 &0.534317 &0.308917\\ \hline 2014-兰州 &0.530212 &0.339574\\ \hline 2020-白银 &0.554296 &0.74971\\ \hline 2019-白银 &0.539683 &0.745783\\ \hline 2018-白银 &0.540519 &0.686521\\ \hline 2017-白银 &0.556932 &0.642665\\ \hline 2016-白银 &0.548147 &0.642956\\ \hline 2015-白银 &0.531137 &0.472456\\ \hline 2014-白银 &0.462768 &0.431706\\ \hline 2020-定西 &0.573853 &0.794995\\ \hline 2019-定西 &0.590623 &0.785911\\ \hline 2018-定西 &0.560645 &0.771887\\ \hline 2017-定西 &0.529441 &0.709237\\ \hline 2016-定西 &0.536585 &0.72762\\ \hline 2015-定西 &0.528439 &0.639354\\ \hline 2014-定西 &0.493915 &0.461692\\ \hline 2020-临夏 &0.476214 &0.782941\\ \hline 2019-临夏 &0.483636 &0.588408\\ \hline 2018-临夏 &0.470437 &0.459976\\ \hline 2017-临夏 &0.476861 &0.474741\\ \hline 2016-临夏 &0.481122 &0.405283\\ \hline 2015-临夏 &0.489754 &0.217145\\ \hline 2014-临夏 &0.494295 &0.297253\\ \hline 2020-西宁 &0.56116 &0.630541\\ \hline 2019-西宁 &0.528266 &0.629296\\ \hline 2018-西宁 &0.488289 &0.601661\\ \hline 2017-西宁 &0.479689 &0.455373\\ \hline 2016-西宁 &0.508665 &0.372617\\ \hline 2015-西宁 &0.558403 &0.396797\\ \hline 2014-西宁 &0.56922 &0.326855\\ \hline 2020-海东 &0.564628 &0.57073\\ \hline 2019-海东 &0.566178 &0.614649\\ \hline 2018-海东 &0.559243 &0.60599\\ \hline 2017-海东 &0.524538 &0.454904\\ \hline 2016-海东 &0.527665 &0.394576\\ \hline 2015-海东 &0.492972 &0.418606\\ \hline 2014-海东 &0.484885 &0.342665\\ \hline \end{array} $$

后悔综合值UR


$$综合值=\begin{array}{c|c|c|c|c|c|c}{M_{42 \times2}} &子系统1 &子系统2\\ \hline 2020-兰州 &0.348905 &0.111004\\ \hline 2019-兰州 &0.33999 &0.116601\\ \hline 2018-兰州 &0.363392 &0.116525\\ \hline 2017-兰州 &0.305667 &0.10723\\ \hline 2016-兰州 &0.305556 &0.108206\\ \hline 2015-兰州 &0.298758 &0.079543\\ \hline 2014-兰州 &0.302101 &0.08932\\ \hline 2020-白银 &0.104799 &0.109389\\ \hline 2019-白银 &0.104068 &0.113887\\ \hline 2018-白银 &0.110246 &0.113887\\ \hline 2017-白银 &0.108563 &0.103838\\ \hline 2016-白银 &0.109219 &0.159443\\ \hline 2015-白银 &0.105048 &0.09147\\ \hline 2014-白银 &0.098679 &0.103272\\ \hline 2020-定西 &0.113307 &0.159599\\ \hline 2019-定西 &0.11088 &0.150078\\ \hline 2018-定西 &0.087834 &0.150078\\ \hline 2017-定西 &0.087276 &0.14679\\ \hline 2016-定西 &0.088068 &0.14679\\ \hline 2015-定西 &0.084699 &0.144863\\ \hline 2014-定西 &0.085747 &0.078779\\ \hline 2020-临夏 &0.082338 &0.146224\\ \hline 2019-临夏 &0.08257 &0.11821\\ \hline 2018-临夏 &0.082841 &0.101761\\ \hline 2017-临夏 &0.083151 &0.089719\\ \hline 2016-临夏 &0.08346 &0.079395\\ \hline 2015-临夏 &0.083924 &0.054694\\ \hline 2014-临夏 &0.084002 &0.082618\\ \hline 2020-西宁 &0.207492 &0.104602\\ \hline 2019-西宁 &0.20972 &0.11821\\ \hline 2018-西宁 &0.190442 &0.100769\\ \hline 2017-西宁 &0.18331 &0.100429\\ \hline 2016-西宁 &0.177181 &0.095101\\ \hline 2015-西宁 &0.207269 &0.095101\\ \hline 2014-西宁 &0.206934 &0.095101\\ \hline 2020-海东 &0.102815 &0.112917\\ \hline 2019-海东 &0.102495 &0.116446\\ \hline 2018-海东 &0.101773 &0.19361\\ \hline 2017-海东 &0.085136 &0.09111\\ \hline 2016-海东 &0.085136 &0.086554\\ \hline 2015-海东 &0.085519 &0.126353\\ \hline 2014-海东 &0.085894 &0.126353\\ \hline \end{array} $$

分配系数采用总系统中的权重分配为0.5500170095778:0.4499829904222

期望 CTD值


$$CTD=\begin{array}{c|c|c|c|c|c|c}{M_{42 \times3}} &C &T &D\\ \hline 2020-兰州 &0.999999 &0.591473 &0.769072\\ \hline 2019-兰州 &0.998483 &0.539698 &0.734084\\ \hline 2018-兰州 &0.999558 &0.504873 &0.710387\\ \hline 2017-兰州 &0.999975 &0.463257 &0.680622\\ \hline 2016-兰州 &0.997677 &0.475422 &0.688707\\ \hline 2015-兰州 &0.963612 &0.432891 &0.645863\\ \hline 2014-兰州 &0.975685 &0.444428 &0.6585\\ \hline 2020-白银 &0.988708 &0.642229 &0.796854\\ \hline 2019-白银 &0.987063 &0.632424 &0.790091\\ \hline 2018-白银 &0.992896 &0.606217 &0.775829\\ \hline 2017-白银 &0.997443 &0.59551 &0.770706\\ \hline 2016-白银 &0.996827 &0.59081 &0.767421\\ \hline 2015-白银 &0.998289 &0.504731 &0.709836\\ \hline 2014-白银 &0.999397 &0.448791 &0.669716\\ \hline 2020-定西 &0.986864 &0.673364 &0.81518\\ \hline 2019-定西 &0.989885 &0.678499 &0.819534\\ \hline 2018-定西 &0.987355 &0.6557 &0.804617\\ \hline 2017-定西 &0.989409 &0.610346 &0.777099\\ \hline 2016-定西 &0.988517 &0.622547 &0.784474\\ \hline 2015-定西 &0.995479 &0.578349 &0.758772\\ \hline 2014-定西 &0.999431 &0.479415 &0.692201\\ \hline 2020-临夏 &0.969877 &0.614236 &0.771837\\ \hline 2019-临夏 &0.995213 &0.530782 &0.726802\\ \hline 2018-临夏 &0.999937 &0.46573 &0.682422\\ \hline 2017-临夏 &0.999998 &0.475907 &0.689859\\ \hline 2016-临夏 &0.996333 &0.446996 &0.66735\\ \hline 2015-临夏 &0.922649 &0.367085 &0.581971\\ \hline 2014-临夏 &0.968521 &0.405629 &0.626786\\ \hline 2020-西宁 &0.998304 &0.59238 &0.769009\\ \hline 2019-西宁 &0.996184 &0.573728 &0.756002\\ \hline 2018-西宁 &0.994576 &0.539304 &0.732379\\ \hline 2017-西宁 &0.999662 &0.468747 &0.684535\\ \hline 2016-西宁 &0.988012 &0.447446 &0.664892\\ \hline 2015-西宁 &0.985584 &0.485683 &0.691868\\ \hline 2014-西宁 &0.962727 &0.46016 &0.665589\\ \hline 2020-海东 &0.999986 &0.567373 &0.753237\\ \hline 2019-海东 &0.999157 &0.587989 &0.766481\\ \hline 2018-海东 &0.999195 &0.580278 &0.761453\\ \hline 2017-海东 &0.99747 &0.493204 &0.701396\\ \hline 2016-海东 &0.989532 &0.467777 &0.680353\\ \hline 2015-海东 &0.996667 &0.459509 &0.67674\\ \hline 2014-海东 &0.985122 &0.420888 &0.643915\\ \hline \end{array} $$

遗憾 CTD值


$$CTD=\begin{array}{c|c|c|c|c|c|c}{M_{42 \times3}} &C &T &D\\ \hline 2020-兰州 &0.855817 &0.241854 &0.454953\\ \hline 2019-兰州 &0.872141 &0.239469 &0.457002\\ \hline 2018-兰州 &0.857554 &0.252306 &0.465151\\ \hline 2017-兰州 &0.876942 &0.216374 &0.4356\\ \hline 2016-兰州 &0.878922 &0.216752 &0.436472\\ \hline 2015-兰州 &0.814991 &0.200115 &0.403846\\ \hline 2014-兰州 &0.839338 &0.206354 &0.416173\\ \hline 2020-白银 &0.99977 &0.106864 &0.326864\\ \hline 2019-白银 &0.998985 &0.108487 &0.329206\\ \hline 2018-白银 &0.999868 &0.111884 &0.334469\\ \hline 2017-白银 &0.999753 &0.106437 &0.326206\\ \hline 2016-白银 &0.982371 &0.131819 &0.359854\\ \hline 2015-白银 &0.99761 &0.098938 &0.314168\\ \hline 2014-白银 &0.999741 &0.100746 &0.317364\\ \hline 2020-定西 &0.985508 &0.134138 &0.363585\\ \hline 2019-定西 &0.988655 &0.128518 &0.356455\\ \hline 2018-定西 &0.965169 &0.115842 &0.334376\\ \hline 2017-定西 &0.967135 &0.114056 &0.332126\\ \hline 2016-定西 &0.968237 &0.114492 &0.33295\\ \hline 2015-定西 &0.965045 &0.111772 &0.328428\\ \hline 2014-定西 &0.999103 &0.082611 &0.287293\\ \hline 2020-临夏 &0.960142 &0.111085 &0.326585\\ \hline 2019-临夏 &0.984119 &0.098608 &0.311515\\ \hline 2018-临夏 &0.994734 &0.091355 &0.301452\\ \hline 2017-临夏 &0.999278 &0.086106 &0.293333\\ \hline 2016-临夏 &0.999688 &0.081631 &0.285666\\ \hline 2015-临夏 &0.977514 &0.070771 &0.26302\\ \hline 2014-临夏 &0.999965 &0.083379 &0.288749\\ \hline 2020-西宁 &0.944094 &0.161193 &0.390104\\ \hline 2019-西宁 &0.960276 &0.168542 &0.402302\\ \hline 2018-西宁 &0.951409 &0.150091 &0.377886\\ \hline 2017-西宁 &0.956387 &0.146015 &0.373693\\ \hline 2016-西宁 &0.953482 &0.140247 &0.365681\\ \hline 2015-西宁 &0.928649 &0.156795 &0.381586\\ \hline 2014-西宁 &0.928927 &0.156612 &0.381419\\ \hline 2020-海东 &0.998903 &0.107361 &0.32748\\ \hline 2019-海东 &0.997968 &0.108773 &0.329472\\ \hline 2018-海东 &0.950439 &0.143098 &0.36879\\ \hline 2017-海东 &0.999425 &0.087824 &0.296266\\ \hline 2016-海东 &0.999966 &0.085774 &0.292867\\ \hline 2015-海东 &0.981252 &0.103894 &0.319289\\ \hline 2014-海东 &0.981663 &0.1041 &0.319674\\ \hline \end{array} $$

排序分析


$$\begin{array}{c|c|c|c|c|c|c}{M_{42 \times2}} &DS &DR\\ \hline 2020-兰州 &0.769072 &0.454953\\ \hline 2019-兰州 &0.734084 &0.457002\\ \hline 2018-兰州 &0.710387 &0.465151\\ \hline 2017-兰州 &0.680622 &0.4356\\ \hline 2016-兰州 &0.688707 &0.436472\\ \hline 2015-兰州 &0.645863 &0.403846\\ \hline 2014-兰州 &0.6585 &0.416173\\ \hline 2020-白银 &0.796854 &0.326864\\ \hline 2019-白银 &0.790091 &0.329206\\ \hline 2018-白银 &0.775829 &0.334469\\ \hline 2017-白银 &0.770706 &0.326206\\ \hline 2016-白银 &0.767421 &0.359854\\ \hline 2015-白银 &0.709836 &0.314168\\ \hline 2014-白银 &0.669716 &0.317364\\ \hline 2020-定西 &0.81518 &0.363585\\ \hline 2019-定西 &0.819534 &0.356455\\ \hline 2018-定西 &0.804617 &0.334376\\ \hline 2017-定西 &0.777099 &0.332126\\ \hline 2016-定西 &0.784474 &0.33295\\ \hline 2015-定西 &0.758772 &0.328428\\ \hline 2014-定西 &0.692201 &0.287293\\ \hline 2020-临夏 &0.771837 &0.326585\\ \hline 2019-临夏 &0.726802 &0.311515\\ \hline 2018-临夏 &0.682422 &0.301452\\ \hline 2017-临夏 &0.689859 &0.293333\\ \hline 2016-临夏 &0.66735 &0.285666\\ \hline 2015-临夏 &0.581971 &0.26302\\ \hline 2014-临夏 &0.626786 &0.288749\\ \hline 2020-西宁 &0.769009 &0.390104\\ \hline 2019-西宁 &0.756002 &0.402302\\ \hline 2018-西宁 &0.732379 &0.377886\\ \hline 2017-西宁 &0.684535 &0.373693\\ \hline 2016-西宁 &0.664892 &0.365681\\ \hline 2015-西宁 &0.691868 &0.381586\\ \hline 2014-西宁 &0.665589 &0.381419\\ \hline 2020-海东 &0.753237 &0.32748\\ \hline 2019-海东 &0.766481 &0.329472\\ \hline 2018-海东 &0.761453 &0.36879\\ \hline 2017-海东 &0.701396 &0.296266\\ \hline 2016-海东 &0.680353 &0.292867\\ \hline 2015-海东 &0.67674 &0.319289\\ \hline 2014-海东 &0.643915 &0.319674\\ \hline \end{array} $$
DS-时间-空间表格 RS-空间-时间表格

$$a_i= DS_i \qquad b_i=DR_i $$

$$ Q_i = \left( 1-k \right) a_i + kb_i \quad \quad $$

对于 $x,y$样本

$$ \begin{cases} \left( 1-k \right) a_x + kb_x \\ \left( 1-k \right) a_y + kb_y \end{cases} $$

以上问题就变成了求两条线段是否在$[0,1]$值域内有相交的问题,此题属于初中的知识范畴,不再详细描述。

$$ \left( 1-k \right) a_x + kb_x =\left( 1-k \right) a_y + kb_y $$

$$ a_x-k a_x + kb_x =a_y-k a_y + kb_y $$

$$ a_x- a_y=-k a_y + kb_y +k a_x - kb_x $$

$$ a_x- a_y=(- a_y + b_y + a_x - b_x)k $$

$$ k =\frac{a_x- a_y}{( a_x- a_y + b_y - b_x)} $$


基础矩阵如下


$$Base=\begin{array}{c|c|c|c|c|c|c}{M_{42 \times2}} &a_i &b_i\\ \hline 2020-兰州 &0.7691 &0.455\\ \hline 2019-兰州 &0.7341 &0.457\\ \hline 2018-兰州 &0.7104 &0.4652\\ \hline 2017-兰州 &0.6806 &0.4356\\ \hline 2016-兰州 &0.6887 &0.4365\\ \hline 2015-兰州 &0.6459 &0.4038\\ \hline 2014-兰州 &0.6585 &0.4162\\ \hline 2020-白银 &0.7969 &0.3269\\ \hline 2019-白银 &0.7901 &0.3292\\ \hline 2018-白银 &0.7758 &0.3345\\ \hline 2017-白银 &0.7707 &0.3262\\ \hline 2016-白银 &0.7674 &0.3599\\ \hline 2015-白银 &0.7098 &0.3142\\ \hline 2014-白银 &0.6697 &0.3174\\ \hline 2020-定西 &0.8152 &0.3636\\ \hline 2019-定西 &0.8195 &0.3565\\ \hline 2018-定西 &0.8046 &0.3344\\ \hline 2017-定西 &0.7771 &0.3321\\ \hline 2016-定西 &0.7845 &0.3329\\ \hline 2015-定西 &0.7588 &0.3284\\ \hline 2014-定西 &0.6922 &0.2873\\ \hline 2020-临夏 &0.7718 &0.3266\\ \hline 2019-临夏 &0.7268 &0.3115\\ \hline 2018-临夏 &0.6824 &0.3015\\ \hline 2017-临夏 &0.6899 &0.2933\\ \hline 2016-临夏 &0.6674 &0.2857\\ \hline 2015-临夏 &0.582 &0.263\\ \hline 2014-临夏 &0.6268 &0.2887\\ \hline 2020-西宁 &0.769 &0.3901\\ \hline 2019-西宁 &0.756 &0.4023\\ \hline 2018-西宁 &0.7324 &0.3779\\ \hline 2017-西宁 &0.6845 &0.3737\\ \hline 2016-西宁 &0.6649 &0.3657\\ \hline 2015-西宁 &0.6919 &0.3816\\ \hline 2014-西宁 &0.6656 &0.3814\\ \hline 2020-海东 &0.7532 &0.3275\\ \hline 2019-海东 &0.7665 &0.3295\\ \hline 2018-海东 &0.7615 &0.3688\\ \hline 2017-海东 &0.7014 &0.2963\\ \hline 2016-海东 &0.6804 &0.2929\\ \hline 2015-海东 &0.6767 &0.3193\\ \hline 2014-海东 &0.6439 &0.3197\\ \hline \end{array} $$

聚类特征


序号 聚类特征-对应k值区段 Q值排序

AEC求解过程


排名 要素所占区段
02015-临夏=1   
12014-临夏=0.929371   2016-临夏=0.070629   
22016-临夏=0.521388   2014-海东=0.407983   2014-临夏=0.048853   2014-定西=0.021776   
32014-定西=0.298154   2016-临夏=0.254137   2014-海东=0.168162   2015-兰州=0.153846   2016-海东=0.103925   2014-临夏=0.021776   
42016-海东=0.593321   2016-临夏=0.090334   2014-白银=0.086568   2014-定西=0.08148   2014-兰州=0.063512   2015-兰州=0.06234   2014-海东=0.022445   
52017-临夏=0.364402   2014-白银=0.23932   2014-定西=0.170757   2016-海东=0.06566   2014-兰州=0.038433   2014-海东=0.037008   2016-临夏=0.033707   2016-西宁=0.029805   2015-兰州=0.020908   
62018-临夏=0.28599   2017-海东=0.214676   2017-临夏=0.157542   2016-西宁=0.123736   2016-海东=0.06195   2014-海东=0.043202   2014-白银=0.027332   2015-兰州=0.02601   2014-定西=0.019323   2014-西宁=0.018065   2016-临夏=0.01174   2014-兰州=0.010434   
72018-临夏=0.472411   2015-海东=0.096474   2014-定西=0.082719   2017-海东=0.074707   2016-西宁=0.04989   2014-西宁=0.042469   2014-白银=0.042237   2014-兰州=0.038169   2014-海东=0.031817   2016-海东=0.024596   2017-临夏=0.022065   2016-临夏=0.018065   2015-兰州=0.004381   
82014-白银=0.20479   2014-海东=0.199775   2017-临夏=0.120256   2017-海东=0.11037   2019-临夏=0.089608   2014-西宁=0.082369   2015-海东=0.08082   2014-定西=0.041318   2018-临夏=0.027188   2015-兰州=0.016988   2016-西宁=0.01098   2014-兰州=0.007893   2016-海东=0.007645   
92014-白银=0.315216   2015-海东=0.307945   2017-海东=0.083133   2017-临夏=0.073864   2015-白银=0.073778   2016-西宁=0.042146   2018-临夏=0.040513   2016-海东=0.022608   2014-西宁=0.013742   2014-兰州=0.010982   2014-海东=0.007437   2014-定西=0.005041   2019-临夏=0.0033219999999999   2015-兰州=0.00027300000000002   
102015-海东=0.380342   2017-海东=0.172478   2016-海东=0.120295   2014-白银=0.084537   2014-西宁=0.059366   2015-兰州=0.047963   2017-临夏=0.04586   2019-临夏=0.041489   2014-定西=0.021061   2016-西宁=0.013741   2014-海东=0.005089   2015-白银=0.003304   2014-兰州=0.003124   2018-临夏=0.001351   
112015-白银=0.455761   2016-西宁=0.195651   2018-临夏=0.159301   2014-海东=0.065514   2014-定西=0.037957   2014-兰州=0.030822   2017-兰州=0.013246   2017-临夏=0.012642   2015-海东=0.011977   2015-兰州=0.007745   2014-西宁=0.004403   2017-海东=0.004182   2019-临夏=0.00079899999999999   
122019-临夏=0.331426   2017-临夏=0.141234   2015-海东=0.122442   2015-兰州=0.075898   2014-西宁=0.075608   2016-西宁=0.067407   2015-白银=0.050805   2017-兰州=0.046214   2017-海东=0.044432   2018-临夏=0.013246   2014-定西=0.013124   2014-海东=0.011568   2014-兰州=0.003921   2017-西宁=0.002675   
132020-海东=0.233905   2016-西宁=0.164769   2014-定西=0.125793   2014-西宁=0.100821   2017-西宁=0.078822   2017-白银=0.06797   2019-临夏=0.066231   2014-兰州=0.056193   2015-兰州=0.050773   2017-海东=0.032539   2015-白银=0.019509   2017-兰州=0.001513   2017-临夏=0.001162   
142014-西宁=0.221097   2015-定西=0.127156   2020-海东=0.101144   2017-西宁=0.097322   2017-白银=0.088963   2017-海东=0.084664   2014-兰州=0.071302   2015-白银=0.062058   2017-临夏=0.052987   2020-临夏=0.045912   2016-西宁=0.017786   2017-兰州=0.011452   2014-定西=0.009072   2016-兰州=0.007986   2015-兰州=0.00083099999999997   2019-临夏=0.00026799999999999   
152017-西宁=0.180092   2017-白银=0.114767   2015-定西=0.11177   2015-兰州=0.093933   2020-临夏=0.077685   2019-临夏=0.062179   2017-兰州=0.057326   2020-海东=0.053166   2014-定西=0.049537   2017-海东=0.049068   2014-兰州=0.045209   2015-白银=0.036516   2014-西宁=0.019537   2016-兰州=0.014902   2020-白银=0.013938   2016-西宁=0.012389   2017-临夏=0.007986   
162017-西宁=0.262303   2020-临夏=0.144108   2015-定西=0.100411   2015-白银=0.087834   2015-西宁=0.087614   2017-白银=0.072671   2017-兰州=0.042582   2016-兰州=0.031572   2017-海东=0.0293   2020-海东=0.027407   2020-白银=0.025511   2015-兰州=0.022489   2014-定西=0.019367   2014-西宁=0.018152   2014-兰州=0.014906   2019-临夏=0.009778   2016-西宁=0.0039950000000001   
172015-西宁=0.285488   2019-海东=0.183687   2014-兰州=0.096131   2020-临夏=0.072705   2019-临夏=0.062213   2015-定西=0.061129   2020-海东=0.052932   2020-白银=0.039633   2016-兰州=0.02853   2017-西宁=0.023496   2017-兰州=0.021596   2017-海东=0.017461   2015-白银=0.016506   2015-兰州=0.015156   2017-白银=0.010919   2016-西宁=0.0049359999999999   2014-西宁=0.003961   2014-定西=0.003521   
182015-西宁=0.18414   2019-海东=0.145345   2020-白银=0.131278   2017-海东=0.08299   2017-兰州=0.077296   2016-兰州=0.064322   2019-临夏=0.061462   2015-白银=0.046617   2015-定西=0.042292   2016-西宁=0.032567   2017-白银=0.028151   2014-兰州=0.025442   2017-定西=0.019842   2015-兰州=0.017025   2020-海东=0.014973   2019-白银=0.011129   2020-临夏=0.009808   2017-西宁=0.004792   2014-西宁=0.000529   
192019-白银=0.1724   2015-白银=0.147312   2017-兰州=0.13055   2020-海东=0.114698   2017-定西=0.103171   2016-兰州=0.086324   2019-海东=0.05239   2019-临夏=0.037589   2014-西宁=0.033339   2015-西宁=0.030145   2017-白银=0.029172   2015-定西=0.023931   2020-白银=0.016935   2014-兰州=0.016838   2016-西宁=0.002907   2015-兰州=0.002019   2020-临夏=0.00026300000000001   2017-西宁=1.6999999999934E-5   
202017-定西=0.186887   2016-兰州=0.138246   2019-临夏=0.137106   2015-定西=0.111613   2018-兰州=0.09653   2019-白银=0.054402   2017-西宁=0.040581   2019-海东=0.039162   2020-白银=0.029949   2020-海东=0.029893   2020-临夏=0.029676   2018-白银=0.029116   2017-白银=0.023381   2014-兰州=0.021342   2017-兰州=0.019923   2014-西宁=0.00786   2016-西宁=0.0016860000000001   2015-西宁=0.001382   2015-兰州=0.0012650000000001   
212016-定西=0.1495   2019-海东=0.132202   2018-兰州=0.104758   2019-临夏=0.09653   2018-西宁=0.091395   2020-海东=0.079199   2018-白银=0.075835   2019-白银=0.057534   2017-定西=0.043478   2015-定西=0.028317   2020-临夏=0.027348   2015-兰州=0.026779   2017-兰州=0.025516   2016-兰州=0.021499   2017-西宁=0.009373   2017-白银=0.009007   2020-白银=0.0084029999999999   2016-西宁=0.006038   2015-西宁=0.003726   2014-西宁=0.003217   2014-兰州=0.00034600000000007   
222018-西宁=0.256562   2018-白银=0.239856   2017-白银=0.1034   2016-定西=0.065395   2020-海东=0.055316   2015-定西=0.045424   2015-西宁=0.040295   2018-兰州=0.036079   2020-临夏=0.033978   2020-白银=0.027945   2016-兰州=0.027534   2019-海东=0.026299   2017-定西=0.013832   2015-兰州=0.0053489999999999   2016-西宁=0.004676   2017-兰州=0.004385   2017-西宁=0.0040289999999999   2014-兰州=0.003518   2018-定西=0.0032219999999999   2014-西宁=0.001873   2019-白银=0.0010330000000001   
232018-定西=0.179815   2019-兰州=0.128821   2020-海东=0.108546   2020-临夏=0.102964   2015-定西=0.08657   2016-定西=0.07472   2018-西宁=0.065324   2017-定西=0.047538   2019-白银=0.044531   2016-西宁=0.031858   2014-兰州=0.026735   2017-白银=0.02511   2018-兰州=0.02402   2018-白银=0.01465   2015-西宁=0.007753   2019-海东=0.007634   2015-兰州=0.007   2016-兰州=0.005574   2017-兰州=0.003954   2014-西宁=0.003934   2017-西宁=0.0022890000000001   2020-白银=0.00065999999999999   
242020-海东=0.128821   2016-西宁=0.126735   2019-海东=0.120778   2015-定西=0.100305   2017-定西=0.090997   2018-定西=0.063621   2019-定西=0.056302   2018-白银=0.051048   2017-西宁=0.047551   2018-西宁=0.041692   2020-白银=0.035321   2019-兰州=0.032261   2018-兰州=0.031116   2020-临夏=0.020793   2017-兰州=0.017238   2015-西宁=0.011654   2016-定西=0.008831   2019-白银=0.0067739999999999   2014-兰州=0.004243   2015-兰州=0.0026320000000001   2017-白银=0.00066500000000003   2016-兰州=0.00058599999999998   2014-西宁=3.5999999999925E-5   
252016-白银=0.135622   2015-定西=0.12494   2017-白银=0.123115   2017-西宁=0.103579   2019-海东=0.089928   2018-白银=0.089301   2019-白银=0.050111   2016-定西=0.045902   2018-西宁=0.045221   2019-兰州=0.041493   2014-西宁=0.0368   2019-西宁=0.036142   2014-兰州=0.012591   2017-定西=0.011751   2018-兰州=0.010206   2017-兰州=0.009713   2020-白银=0.00811   2018-定西=0.0061639999999999   2019-定西=0.004931   2020-临夏=0.004071   2016-兰州=0.003614   2015-西宁=0.003455   2016-西宁=0.0025259999999999   2015-兰州=0.00071399999999999   
262020-临夏=0.123462   2016-定西=0.116652   2019-西宁=0.089648   2017-白银=0.083964   2014-西宁=0.07806   2019-海东=0.076785   2019-定西=0.052001   2018-定西=0.042315   2016-西宁=0.040019   2016-白银=0.03914   2018-西宁=0.036695   2015-定西=0.036142   2015-西宁=0.032659   2017-西宁=0.029845   2016-兰州=0.027923   2017-定西=0.023892   2019-兰州=0.01617   2018-白银=0.015279   2020-定西=0.013757   2015-兰州=0.011596   2020-白银=0.0049560000000001   2018-兰州=0.004518   2017-兰州=0.002411   2019-白银=0.0020210000000001   2014-兰州=9.0000000000034E-5   
272018-海东=0.151958   2017-定西=0.10717   2015-西宁=0.088305   2020-临夏=0.082732   2020-定西=0.058062   2019-白银=0.057618   2020-白银=0.049648   2016-白银=0.048622   2018-白银=0.042021   2017-西宁=0.041415   2017-白银=0.040251   2016-定西=0.036091   2014-西宁=0.035226   2018-兰州=0.02645   2019-定西=0.026302   2015-兰州=0.021693   2017-兰州=0.017994   2019-西宁=0.014125   2016-西宁=0.013757   2019-海东=0.012411   2018-定西=0.0092570000000001   2019-兰州=0.00575   2018-西宁=0.0055580000000001   2014-兰州=0.0055369999999999   2016-兰州=0.002047   
282018-海东=0.191922   2018-白银=0.147684   2019-海东=0.113379   2015-西宁=0.05891   2018-定西=0.0545   2020-白银=0.049473   2016-白银=0.04235   2015-兰州=0.03866   2019-白银=0.035325   2014-兰州=0.033393   2020-临夏=0.027039   2019-定西=0.024938   2014-西宁=0.023129   2016-定西=0.022367   2019-西宁=0.022024   2016-兰州=0.019883   2017-定西=0.017443   2017-白银=0.016555   2020-定西=0.016507   2018-西宁=0.015793   2019-兰州=0.012302   2017-西宁=0.011889   2017-兰州=0.0042129999999999   2018-兰州=0.00032199999999999   
292018-海东=0.212791   2016-白银=0.16295   2016-定西=0.089444   2017-白银=0.073001   2018-西宁=0.067461   2017-西宁=0.05993   2020-白银=0.04158   2018-白银=0.041098   2017-定西=0.034905   2015-兰州=0.033027   2020-临夏=0.024489   2019-白银=0.021218   2020-定西=0.018196   2014-兰州=0.017548   2019-兰州=0.017315   2018-定西=0.017005   2018-兰州=0.012384   2019-西宁=0.011028   2019-定西=0.010699   2014-西宁=0.009885   2017-兰州=0.009538   2015-西宁=0.009146   2016-兰州=0.005362   
302018-西宁=0.219697   2016-白银=0.190224   2018-海东=0.08205   2017-白银=0.063075   2019-白银=0.060725   2014-西宁=0.056275   2020-临夏=0.055779   2017-定西=0.040374   2019-西宁=0.039022   2018-定西=0.030614   2015-西宁=0.027942   2020-西宁=0.025863   2019-定西=0.022189   2020-定西=0.020864   2020-白银=0.020015   2017-兰州=0.01734   2016-兰州=0.010741   2018-白银=0.005303   2018-兰州=0.004962   2016-定西=0.003161   2015-兰州=0.001897   2019-兰州=0.001374   2014-兰州=0.00051400000000001   
312016-白银=0.345851   2018-海东=0.105145   2018-西宁=0.09102   2020-临夏=0.074563   2014-西宁=0.050247   2015-西宁=0.043689   2018-定西=0.03709   2016-定西=0.028795   2014-兰州=0.02565   2020-白银=0.025138   2018-白银=0.022626   2020-定西=0.019893   2019-定西=0.017019   2020-西宁=0.016762   2015-兰州=0.016429   2019-西宁=0.014194   2017-兰州=0.013484   2017-白银=0.013335   2020-兰州=0.012528   2016-兰州=0.010103   2018-兰州=0.007797   2019-白银=0.005408   2017-定西=0.002514   2019-兰州=0.00072   
322018-海东=0.19591   2018-白银=0.116989   2015-西宁=0.083697   2016-定西=0.068092   2020-西宁=0.066569   2018-西宁=0.063582   2019-定西=0.056141   2019-白银=0.050171   2020-定西=0.044829   2014-兰州=0.04466   2016-白银=0.035241   2019-兰州=0.029861   2017-定西=0.025066   2015-兰州=0.022273   2020-临夏=0.021539   2020-白银=0.0137   2017-白银=0.012528   2016-兰州=0.011283   2018-兰州=0.010458   2019-西宁=0.00994   2020-兰州=0.008558   2018-定西=0.005843   2017-兰州=0.00307   
332020-西宁=0.113637   2017-定西=0.1087   2019-定西=0.092434   2015-兰州=0.091717   2017-兰州=0.08649   2019-西宁=0.081914   2020-白银=0.073089   2018-海东=0.060224   2020-定西=0.05919   2018-白银=0.056093   2019-白银=0.051563   2020-兰州=0.032015   2020-临夏=0.021086   2014-兰州=0.019224   2018-定西=0.01887   2018-兰州=0.015118   2016-兰州=0.013653   2019-兰州=0.002794   2016-定西=0.002189   
342020-西宁=0.180994   2018-定西=0.112892   2020-定西=0.097322   2016-兰州=0.088808   2015-兰州=0.086567   2016-定西=0.07591   2017-定西=0.061103   2014-兰州=0.060424   2018-白银=0.053101   2019-西宁=0.047081   2018-兰州=0.034074   2020-白银=0.033424   2019-定西=0.016552   2019-兰州=0.015849   2017-兰州=0.014336   2019-白银=0.013327   2020-兰州=0.008236   
352020-西宁=0.278558   2019-西宁=0.272075   2016-定西=0.100865   2014-兰州=0.066329   2017-定西=0.061337   2020-兰州=0.050749   2019-白银=0.047557   2020-白银=0.025906   2019-兰州=0.020678   2019-定西=0.02025   2020-定西=0.01621   2015-兰州=0.013824   2016-兰州=0.013456   2017-兰州=0.0088020000000001   2018-兰州=0.001763   2018-定西=0.001641   
362019-西宁=0.250038   2020-西宁=0.231615   2014-兰州=0.124545   2019-白银=0.113944   2016-定西=0.112086   2017-兰州=0.033428   2020-兰州=0.031123   2018-定西=0.027293   2020-白银=0.019687   2019-定西=0.019401   2018-兰州=0.018007   2019-兰州=0.017611   2020-定西=0.000776   2016-兰州=0.00044600000000006   
372017-兰州=0.30639   2019-白银=0.143209   2020-白银=0.127465   2020-西宁=0.086002   2019-定西=0.079806   2018-兰州=0.062473   2019-西宁=0.054033   2020-兰州=0.035027   2020-定西=0.029894   2016-兰州=0.028842   2018-定西=0.024702   2019-兰州=0.022157   
382016-兰州=0.336764   2020-白银=0.178236   2018-定西=0.137482   2020-定西=0.096683   2019-兰州=0.09426   2019-西宁=0.058736   2020-兰州=0.049438   2019-定西=0.041619   2018-兰州=0.006782   
392018-兰州=0.236283   2018-定西=0.227674   2019-兰州=0.205874   2020-兰州=0.163019   2020-定西=0.086895   2019-定西=0.080255   
402020-定西=0.420922   2019-兰州=0.33471   2018-兰州=0.107852   2020-兰州=0.096115   2019-定西=0.040401   
412020-兰州=0.513192   2019-定西=0.33876   2018-兰州=0.148048   
排名 最优妥协解
劣汰情境$2015-临夏 \prec 2014-临夏 \prec 2016-临夏 \prec 2014-海东 \prec 2016-海东 \prec 2014-定西 \prec 2017-临夏 \prec 2018-临夏 \prec 2014-白银 \prec 2015-海东 \prec 2017-海东 \prec 2015-白银 \prec 2016-西宁 \prec 2019-临夏 \prec 2014-西宁 \prec 2015-兰州 \prec 2017-西宁 \prec 2014-兰州 \prec 2015-西宁 \prec 2020-海东 \prec 2015-定西 \prec 2019-海东 \prec 2017-白银 \prec 2020-临夏 \prec 2017-定西 \prec 2018-西宁 \prec 2018-白银 \prec 2017-兰州 \prec 2016-定西 \prec 2018-海东 \prec 2016-白银 \prec 2019-白银 \prec 2020-白银 \prec 2016-兰州 \prec 2018-定西 \prec 2020-西宁 \prec 2019-西宁 \prec 2018-兰州 \prec 2019-定西 \prec 2019-兰州 \prec 2020-定西 \prec 2020-兰州$
优胜情境 $2015-临夏 \prec 2014-临夏 \prec 2016-临夏 \prec 2014-海东 \prec 2016-海东 \prec 2014-定西 \prec 2017-临夏 \prec 2018-临夏 \prec 2014-白银 \prec 2015-海东 \prec 2017-海东 \prec 2015-白银 \prec 2016-西宁 \prec 2019-临夏 \prec 2014-西宁 \prec 2015-兰州 \prec 2017-西宁 \prec 2014-兰州 \prec 2015-西宁 \prec 2020-海东 \prec 2015-定西 \prec 2019-海东 \prec 2017-白银 \prec 2020-临夏 \prec 2017-定西 \prec 2018-西宁 \prec 2018-白银 \prec 2016-定西 \prec 2019-白银 \prec 2018-海东 \prec 2016-白银 \prec 2017-兰州 \prec 2020-白银 \prec 2016-兰州 \prec 2020-西宁 \prec 2019-西宁 \prec 2018-定西 \prec 2018-兰州 \prec 2019-定西 \prec 2019-兰州 \prec 2020-定西 \prec 2020-兰州$

求解妥协解的具体值


落在了第184个拐点上,值为:0.48590388177395

$$\begin{array}{c|c|c|c|c|c|c}{M_{42 \times3}} &DS &DR &最优妥协解\\ \hline 2020-兰州 &0.7691 &0.455 &0.6164\\ \hline 2019-兰州 &0.7341 &0.457 &0.5994\\ \hline 2018-兰州 &0.7104 &0.4652 &0.5912\\ \hline 2017-兰州 &0.6806 &0.4356 &0.5616\\ \hline 2016-兰州 &0.6887 &0.4365 &0.5661\\ \hline 2015-兰州 &0.6459 &0.4038 &0.5283\\ \hline 2014-兰州 &0.6585 &0.4162 &0.5408\\ \hline 2020-白银 &0.7969 &0.3269 &0.5685\\ \hline 2019-白银 &0.7901 &0.3292 &0.5661\\ \hline 2018-白银 &0.7758 &0.3345 &0.5614\\ \hline 2017-白银 &0.7707 &0.3262 &0.5547\\ \hline 2016-白银 &0.7674 &0.3599 &0.5694\\ \hline 2015-白银 &0.7098 &0.3142 &0.5176\\ \hline 2014-白银 &0.6697 &0.3174 &0.4985\\ \hline 2020-定西 &0.8152 &0.3636 &0.5957\\ \hline 2019-定西 &0.8195 &0.3565 &0.5945\\ \hline 2018-定西 &0.8046 &0.3344 &0.5761\\ \hline 2017-定西 &0.7771 &0.3321 &0.5609\\ \hline 2016-定西 &0.7845 &0.3329 &0.5651\\ \hline 2015-定西 &0.7588 &0.3284 &0.5497\\ \hline 2014-定西 &0.6922 &0.2873 &0.4955\\ \hline 2020-临夏 &0.7718 &0.3266 &0.5555\\ \hline 2019-临夏 &0.7268 &0.3115 &0.525\\ \hline 2018-临夏 &0.6824 &0.3015 &0.4973\\ \hline 2017-临夏 &0.6899 &0.2933 &0.4972\\ \hline 2016-临夏 &0.6674 &0.2857 &0.4819\\ \hline 2015-临夏 &0.582 &0.263 &0.427\\ \hline 2014-临夏 &0.6268 &0.2887 &0.4625\\ \hline 2020-西宁 &0.769 &0.3901 &0.5849\\ \hline 2019-西宁 &0.756 &0.4023 &0.5841\\ \hline 2018-西宁 &0.7324 &0.3779 &0.5601\\ \hline 2017-西宁 &0.6845 &0.3737 &0.5335\\ \hline 2016-西宁 &0.6649 &0.3657 &0.5195\\ \hline 2015-西宁 &0.6919 &0.3816 &0.5411\\ \hline 2014-西宁 &0.6656 &0.3814 &0.5275\\ \hline 2020-海东 &0.7532 &0.3275 &0.5464\\ \hline 2019-海东 &0.7665 &0.3295 &0.5541\\ \hline 2018-海东 &0.7615 &0.3688 &0.5707\\ \hline 2017-海东 &0.7014 &0.2963 &0.5045\\ \hline 2016-海东 &0.6804 &0.2929 &0.4921\\ \hline 2015-海东 &0.6767 &0.3193 &0.5031\\ \hline 2014-海东 &0.6439 &0.3197 &0.4864\\ \hline \end{array} $$

落在了第185个拐点上,值为:0.49103095397492

$$\begin{array}{c|c|c|c|c|c|c}{M_{42 \times3}} &DS &DR &最优妥协解\\ \hline 2020-兰州 &0.7691 &0.455 &0.6148\\ \hline 2019-兰州 &0.7341 &0.457 &0.598\\ \hline 2018-兰州 &0.7104 &0.4652 &0.59\\ \hline 2017-兰州 &0.6806 &0.4356 &0.5603\\ \hline 2016-兰州 &0.6887 &0.4365 &0.5649\\ \hline 2015-兰州 &0.6459 &0.4038 &0.527\\ \hline 2014-兰州 &0.6585 &0.4162 &0.5395\\ \hline 2020-白银 &0.7969 &0.3269 &0.5661\\ \hline 2019-白银 &0.7901 &0.3292 &0.5638\\ \hline 2018-白银 &0.7758 &0.3345 &0.5591\\ \hline 2017-白银 &0.7707 &0.3262 &0.5524\\ \hline 2016-白银 &0.7674 &0.3599 &0.5673\\ \hline 2015-白银 &0.7098 &0.3142 &0.5156\\ \hline 2014-白银 &0.6697 &0.3174 &0.4967\\ \hline 2020-定西 &0.8152 &0.3636 &0.5934\\ \hline 2019-定西 &0.8195 &0.3565 &0.5921\\ \hline 2018-定西 &0.8046 &0.3344 &0.5737\\ \hline 2017-定西 &0.7771 &0.3321 &0.5586\\ \hline 2016-定西 &0.7845 &0.3329 &0.5628\\ \hline 2015-定西 &0.7588 &0.3284 &0.5475\\ \hline 2014-定西 &0.6922 &0.2873 &0.4934\\ \hline 2020-临夏 &0.7718 &0.3266 &0.5532\\ \hline 2019-临夏 &0.7268 &0.3115 &0.5229\\ \hline 2018-临夏 &0.6824 &0.3015 &0.4954\\ \hline 2017-临夏 &0.6899 &0.2933 &0.4952\\ \hline 2016-临夏 &0.6674 &0.2857 &0.4799\\ \hline 2015-临夏 &0.582 &0.263 &0.4254\\ \hline 2014-临夏 &0.6268 &0.2887 &0.4608\\ \hline 2020-西宁 &0.769 &0.3901 &0.583\\ \hline 2019-西宁 &0.756 &0.4023 &0.5823\\ \hline 2018-西宁 &0.7324 &0.3779 &0.5583\\ \hline 2017-西宁 &0.6845 &0.3737 &0.5319\\ \hline 2016-西宁 &0.6649 &0.3657 &0.518\\ \hline 2015-西宁 &0.6919 &0.3816 &0.5395\\ \hline 2014-西宁 &0.6656 &0.3814 &0.5261\\ \hline 2020-海东 &0.7532 &0.3275 &0.5442\\ \hline 2019-海东 &0.7665 &0.3295 &0.5519\\ \hline 2018-海东 &0.7615 &0.3688 &0.5686\\ \hline 2017-海东 &0.7014 &0.2963 &0.5025\\ \hline 2016-海东 &0.6804 &0.2929 &0.4901\\ \hline 2015-海东 &0.6767 &0.3193 &0.5012\\ \hline 2014-海东 &0.6439 &0.3197 &0.4847\\ \hline \end{array} $$
扯蛋模型